Online age checks for harmful content

Summary#

North Dakota SB 2380 creates a new section in Chapter 51-07 of the North Dakota Century Code; it does not amend a named existing section. Its stated goal is to make certain commercial entities liable for publishing or distributing sexual material harmful to minors without age verification. The supplied status says it is enacted, but the materials do not give its effective date.

  • A commercial entity that knowingly publishes or distributes the defined material online must use a reasonable age-verification method if more than one-third of the material on its website is harmful to minors.
  • The entity, or a third party verifying age for it, may not keep identifying information after access is granted.
  • A parent or guardian whose minor child was allowed access in violation of the age-verification rule, or a person whose identifying information was improperly kept, may sue. A court may order an injunction and award compensatory or exemplary damages, costs, and reasonable attorney fees.
  • The section does not apply to bona fide news or public-interest broadcasts, website videos, reports, or events, and must not affect news-gathering organizations’ rights.
  • Internet service providers, search engines, cloud service providers, and app stores are not liable solely for providing access or connections if they did not create the content and it is outside their control.

What it means for you#

  • Commercial entities: If your website meets the bill’s “substantial portion” threshold and you knowingly publish or distribute the defined material, you must verify that people seeking access are at least 18. The bill lists methods including digitized ID, government-issued ID, certain databases, and commercially reasonable methods using public or private transaction data.
  • Minors and their parents or guardians: A parent or guardian may sue if their minor child was allowed access in violation of the age-verification rule. The bill does not create a separate service or process for families to seek help.
  • People whose information is used for age checks: The verifier may not retain identifying information after access is granted. A person whose information is retained in violation may sue.
  • Age-verification companies: A third party that verifies age for a commercial entity must not retain identifying information after access is granted. The bill allows a lawsuit against such a third party, though its wording about when the third party itself is liable for damages is unclear.
  • News organizations and internet intermediaries: The stated news and public-interest exception applies, and specified intermediaries are protected from liability solely for providing access or connections when they did not create the content. These provisions are not a general exemption for every website or service.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost of implementing or enforcing the law.

  • The bill authorizes civil damages and court orders, including attorney fees, but sets no dollar amount or limit for damages.
  • It does not set a fee, tax, fine, or public funding amount.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not give the effective date, beyond saying the law applies to websites accessed on or after that date.
  • “Commercially reasonable” age-verification methods and some other key terms are not defined in the text.
  • The bill does not set rules for how verification must work, how compliance is checked, or how a person brings a claim beyond authorizing civil actions.
  • It allows actions against a third-party verifier, but says a commercial entity found to have violated the relevant rules is liable for damages. The text does not clearly explain when the third party is itself liable for damages.
  • The parent law and other current North Dakota laws are not supplied, so it is not possible to verify how this new section would interact with existing rules.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to restrict minors’ access to websites where more than one-third of the content meets its definition of sexual material harmful to minors.
  • A possible argument for the approach is that it places the age-check duty on commercial entities publishing or distributing that material, rather than on all websites.
  • The bill permits several verification methods and bars keeping identifying information after access is granted.
  • The news and public-interest exception and the limits on intermediary liability narrow who is covered.

Case against#

  • One concern is that age checks may require people to provide ID or data from commercial databases or transactions, even though identifying information cannot be retained after access is granted.
  • The bill does not explain how age-verification systems should protect information while checking it, or how people can challenge an error.
  • The definition of harmful material and the threshold based on a website’s content may leave room for disagreement about which websites must comply.
  • The bill allows compensatory and exemplary damages and attorney fees but does not set amounts or limits, leaving the potential financial exposure unclear.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1552990

    Passed47 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    FOR · 47

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    47For

    • Republican42
    • Democratic5

    0Against

  2. Division No. 1494017

    Passed47 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    FOR · 46AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    46For

    • Republican42
    • Democratic4

    1Against

    • Democratic1