Ban on DEI in colleges proposed

Summary#

SB-2392, titled “The regulation of prohibited discriminatory practices; and to provide for a legislative management report,” would have created new chapters and a new section in North Dakota law; it does not name an existing Act it would amend. Its stated goal was to regulate prohibited discriminatory practices and require reports. The bill failed to pass, so it did not change the law.

  • At public colleges and universities, it would have banned a broad range of practices, including practices labeled “diversity, equity, and inclusion”; offices and staff roles set up to promote them; and required training that promotes them.
  • It would have barred higher-education institutions and school districts from requiring or preferring certain identity-related submissions in specified employment, admission, aid, and program decisions. Federal-law requirements and listed work-related disclosures would be exceptions.
  • It would have barred state and local government employers from requiring or preferring those submissions, and from requiring training that promotes prohibited practices. Federal-law requirements would be excepted.
  • It would have required higher-education institutions to provide annual training on academic freedom and freedom of speech, and to publish mandatory course and training titles and syllabi. It also would have required them to promote viewpoint diversity and provide education and research opportunities on free speech and civic education.
  • It would have set up oversight using existing bodies: the State Board of Higher Education, the Department of Public Instruction, agency directors, the governor, and the state auditor. The board could make rules for higher-education complaint procedures; the department would set complaint procedures for school districts.
  • After a violation at a higher-education institution, the board would have had to work with it on a remediation plan within 30 days and allow 180 days to fix the violation. The Legislative Assembly could withhold future state appropriations if the institution did not fix it in time.

What it means for you#

  • Everyone: The bill is not law. Its proposed bans, duties, and complaint procedures did not take effect.
  • Public-college students and employees: If enacted, the bill would have barred institutions from requiring certain submissions or giving preference for them in employment, admission, advancement, graduation, institutional programs, or state aid. It would also have barred the listed practices, offices, and roles, and required annual speech and academic-freedom training for faculty and staff.
  • Public-school students and employees: School districts would have had to ensure all students could access student-success and support programs. The bill would have barred districts from requiring or preferring certain submissions in employment, enrollment, graduation, district programs, or state assistance.
  • State and local public employees and applicants: Government employers—including political subdivisions and state bodies, but not school districts or public higher-education institutions—would have faced the proposed bans on certain submissions, preferential consideration, training, offices, and staff duties.
  • Taxpayers: The bill did not set a tax, fee, fine, or benefit amount. It did allow the legislature to withhold future state appropriations from a higher-education institution that failed to cure a violation.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would have required reviews, reports, complaint procedures, and specified training, but gives no cost estimate or staffing amount.
  • It would have allowed—but not required—the Legislative Assembly to withhold future appropriations from a non-compliant higher-education institution.

What is unclear#

  • “Prohibited discriminatory practice” covers many statements and activities, including practices named “diversity, equity, and inclusion,” but the bill does not explain how borderline cases would be decided.
  • The bill does not define some key terms, including “important government interest,” or explain how its broad bans would apply to particular lessons, research, programs, or public statements.
  • It does not give detailed rules for investigating complaints or deciding them. The Board of Higher Education and Department of Public Instruction would have had to create complaint procedures.
  • It does not explain how the proposed restrictions would interact with existing programs beyond exceptions for policies required by state or federal law.
  • The bill does not provide a general start date or implementation budget. Its review dates are specified, but the bill failed to pass.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that people should not have to state or document personal views as a condition of employment, admission, advancement, or aid.
  • Its limits on using identity characteristics in decisions could be seen as promoting neutral treatment, while the legal-compliance exceptions would preserve policies required by state or federal law.
  • The required public course and training information, complaint procedures, reviews, and reports could make institutional practices more visible and provide a way to raise concerns.
  • Requiring student-success programs to be open to all students could protect access to support services.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the definition of prohibited practices is broad. It includes named approaches and topics, and higher-education institutions would also be barred from taking or expressing positions on several listed subjects.
  • It is unclear how institutions could distinguish prohibited practices from legitimate teaching, research, training, or discussion, particularly where the bill leaves key terms undefined.
  • The bill would have required reviews, reports, complaint systems, and annual training without specifying funding or staffing.
  • A possible trade-off is that broad restrictions intended to prevent identity-based treatment could also limit how institutions discuss or address discrimination, beyond what state or federal law requires.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1498124

    Defeated47 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    AGAINST · 46FOR · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    46Against

    • Republican41
    • Democratic5

    1For

    • Republican1