Foreign land-ownership limits extended for review

Summary#

SB 2361, titled “Ownership of land and development projects by a foreign adversary; and to provide for a legislative management report,” would amend three sections of the North Dakota Century Code and require a state report. It would extend existing restrictions on foreign-adversary land ownership and local development approvals by two years; its stated goal is to assess and recommend ways to address foreign influence and related risks. The bill failed to pass the Senate, so it did not change the law.

  • The bill would extend the expiry date for limits on county and city development agreements, building plans, or proposals involving a foreign adversary from July 31, 2025, to July 31, 2027.
  • It would extend through July 31, 2027, the restriction on certain foreign adversaries and related business entities buying or otherwise acquiring North Dakota real estate. The text includes an exception for a qualifying business that has been in good standing for at least seven years before August 1, 2023, has federal Committee on Foreign Investment approval, and maintains an active national security agreement.
  • The Department of Emergency Services would have to assess risks across sectors, including infrastructure, technology, agriculture, energy, and academia, and report recommendations by July 1, 2026.
  • The department’s report would have to propose the structure and operation of a state intelligence unit. The bill would not create that unit.
  • The department would have to present the report’s recommendations and any proposed legislation to Legislative Management before September 1, 2026. The report’s findings would be exempt from public records disclosure under the cited law.

What it means for you#

  • North Dakota residents: Since SB 2361 failed, it creates no new restrictions or duties. The available material does not include the current versions of the amended laws, so I could not verify the full current law or all differences against it.
  • County and city governments: If enacted, the bill would extend the existing limits on approving or arranging certain development projects with a foreign adversary. The bill does not set up a new application or review process.
  • Foreign adversaries and certain business entities: If enacted, the land-acquisition restriction would remain in effect through July 31, 2027. The text retains provisions for divestment, court-ordered divestment, and a civil penalty of up to $25,000 for failing to comply with a court order. It also says people not subject to the restriction do not have to determine whether someone else is subject to it.
  • The public: The bill would require a risk assessment and recommendations, not an operating intelligence unit or a new front-line service. The proposed report’s findings would not be publicly available under the bill’s records provision.

Money#

The bill text provided gives no cost estimate or appropriation amount.

  • The Department of Emergency Services would have to prepare and present the report, but the bill does not state how many staff or what resources that would require.
  • The section heading mentions “one-time funding,” but the provided text contains no amount or operative appropriation.

What is unclear#

  • The current versions of the amended laws were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify how much of the re-enacted wording is already in effect or what other provisions may change.
  • The local-government sections refer to federal foreign-adversary designations and the federal sanctions list, but the supplied text contains inconsistent-looking citations. The exact reference should be checked against the enacted bill text.
  • The report must assess “foreign adversarial influence,” but the bill does not define that term or set limits on what activities qualify.
  • The bill does not specify the department’s methods, public input, or how it would evaluate existing investments and activities.
  • The report must be exempt from public disclosure, but the bill does not explain what information, if any, could be made public in a separate summary.
  • The bill does not provide the funding or staff needed for the report.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that extending the restrictions would keep them in force while the state assesses risks and develops recommendations.
  • The report would look beyond land purchases to investments, partnerships, and other economic, educational, and political influence.
  • Requiring sector-specific recommendations could help identify risks that land-ownership rules alone do not address.
  • Asking the department to propose an intelligence unit, rather than creating one immediately, would let lawmakers consider its structure and powers before deciding whether to establish it.

Case against#

  • The bill would extend restrictions on local development approvals and real-estate acquisition without adding detailed decision rules or a process for resolving difficult cases.
  • It would require a wide-ranging assessment but gives no cost estimate, funding amount, or staffing plan.
  • Keeping the report’s findings exempt from public disclosure could limit public scrutiny of the department’s assessment and recommendations.
  • The bill asks for a proposal for a state intelligence unit but does not set boundaries for that unit’s possible monitoring powers; those details would be left for a later proposal.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1491491

    Defeated45 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    AGAINST · 44FOR · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    44Against

    • Republican39
    • Democratic5

    1For

    • Republican1

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.