Lawmakers consider study on pornography impacts

Summary#

SCR 4017 is an enacted concurrent resolution, not a law that creates a new program or changes rules for the public. It directs North Dakota’s Legislative Management to consider studying pornography’s detrimental impacts; its stated goal is to examine the issue and possible policy changes.

  • Legislative Management is not required to conduct the study: it is asked to consider doing so.
  • If a study is undertaken, it is to examine current education, prevention, and research efforts; consider possible policy changes; and include input from relevant state agencies and other stakeholders.
  • The resolution directs the study’s findings and recommendations, along with any legislation needed to carry them out, to be reported to the Seventieth Legislative Assembly.

What it means for you#

  • People who use or provide pornography: The resolution does not ban pornography, change access rules, impose a fee or penalty, or create a new service.
  • Legislative Management and agencies: Legislative Management must consider whether to study the issue. If it does, the resolution sets out topics for the study and calls for input from relevant agencies and other stakeholders.
  • The public: If a study is conducted, its findings and recommendations are to go to the Seventieth Legislative Assembly. The resolution does not require a public hearing or specify how people can provide input.

Money#

No cost information is in the supplied material.

  • The resolution does not include an appropriation or estimate the cost of a study.
  • It does not say whether additional staff or other resources would be needed if a study is undertaken.

What is unclear#

  • Whether Legislative Management will choose to conduct the study.
  • What evidence, methods, or definition of “pornography” a study would use.
  • Which agencies and other stakeholders would be included, or how they could give input.
  • How a study would be funded or staffed.
  • The resolution does not require the study to examine possible benefits or other effects alongside detrimental impacts.

Case for#

  • A study could bring existing education, prevention, and research efforts together for lawmakers to consider.
  • Examining possible policy changes could give the Legislature information before deciding whether new legislation is needed.
  • The report could identify recommendations and any legislation needed to carry them out.

Case against#

  • The resolution asks Legislative Management only to consider a study, so it does not ensure that the study or report will happen.
  • It calls for a study of detrimental impacts but does not specify methods or evidence standards; those choices could shape the findings.
  • The resolution does not identify funding, staffing, or how input from agencies and other stakeholders would be gathered.