Clerks' home addresses would be exempt

Summary#

HB 1007, “Prevent Public Record Law release of clerk of court personal info,” is an introduced bill to amend Ohio Revised Code §149.43, the Public Records Law. Its stated goal is to prevent the release of clerks of court’s personal information, but the wording supplied appears to leave clerks’ home addresses outside the law’s personal-information exemption.

  • The bill text lists a clerk of court’s actual home address among information that is not covered by the exemption for designated public service workers.
  • Clerks of court are already included in the bill’s list of designated public service workers. The apparent change concerns their actual home addresses, not every kind of personal information.
  • The text does not create a new office, program, fine, or request process.
  • The bill is not law. Its stated goal and the wording supplied appear to conflict.

What it means for you#

  • Clerks of court: Under the wording supplied, their actual home addresses would not be protected by this particular Public Records Law exemption. Other exemptions could still apply.
  • Public offices handling records requests: The bill does not set out new steps for processing requests. It would affect which personal information is covered by this exemption.
  • People requesting records: The bill does not directly change the general right to request public records. The supplied wording does not appear to make clerks’ home addresses confidential under this exemption.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not state an appropriation, fee, fine, staffing requirement, or cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The bill’s title says it would prevent release of clerks’ personal information, but the supplied wording appears to place clerks’ actual home addresses among the exceptions to the exemption. The available material does not resolve this conflict.
  • The current version of Ohio Revised Code §149.43 was not supplied, so the exact change from current law could not be verified.
  • The text addresses actual home addresses; it does not explain whether the bill is intended to protect other kinds of clerk information.
  • The bill is at the introduced stage. The available material does not establish whether it will pass or provide a start date.

Case for#

  • The bill’s stated goal is to prevent public release of clerks’ personal information.
  • If the intended change is to protect clerks’ home addresses, a possible argument is that public access to records need not include that specific personal detail.
  • The bill appears to aim for a targeted change to the Public Records Law rather than a broad change to public access.

Case against#

  • The supplied wording appears to undermine the stated goal: it places clerks’ actual home addresses outside the exemption for designated public service workers.
  • Because the text and title point in different directions, the bill’s practical effect is uncertain.
  • The available material does not show how the proposed wording compares with current law, making it harder to assess the exact change.