Limit license-plate data access

Summary#

HB 1009, the Stop Flock Abuse Act, would add three new sections to Ohio’s Revised Code. It would restrict access to and handling of data from automated license plate readers and other defined mass-surveillance technology, with several exceptions. Its stated goal is to regulate the use of these systems; the bill does not promise a particular result.

  • Private persons and government entities generally could not knowingly access, collect, use, sell, transfer, or share the covered data, unless an exception applies.
  • Law enforcement agencies and peace officers could handle the data during law enforcement activities. A peace officer could not handle it beyond the scope of the officer’s duties.
  • Exceptions also cover normal business or government activity, court-authorized access, certain toll cameras, and traffic photo-monitoring devices operated under state law or a substantially equivalent municipal ordinance.
  • A private person or peace officer who violates the stated restrictions would commit a fifth-degree felony. The bill does not set out a penalty for a government entity that violates its restriction.
  • The bill does not ban owning or using the technology itself. It regulates specified handling of the data it captures.

What it means for you#

  • Members of the public: The bill does not create a process for people to find out whether data about them was captured, request its deletion, or challenge its use.
  • Businesses and other private persons: They would generally be barred from knowingly handling covered data, but the normal-business-activity exception could allow handling within the scope of their normal duties. The bill does not explain how that exception applies to particular activities.
  • Government entities: They would face the general restriction, subject to exceptions. The bill gives no specific penalty for violating it.
  • Law enforcement: Agencies could handle the data in their law enforcement activities. Peace officers could not handle it beyond their duties; a violation would be a fifth-degree felony.
  • Toll operators and traffic enforcement: Certain toll cameras could be used only for toll billing, must meet specified existing legal requirements, and could not be integrated with a law-enforcement database or accessible to law enforcement without a warrant. Qualifying traffic photo-monitoring devices are also exempt.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not state a spending amount, provide for new staffing, or set fees or fines.
  • It creates a felony penalty for violations by private persons or peace officers, but gives no estimate of enforcement costs.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include current Ohio law, so it is not possible to verify what restrictions or protections already apply or how this bill would overlap with them.
  • “Normal business activity” and “normal activities” are not defined. The bill does not explain how broad those exceptions would be.
  • The bill does not set rules for data retention, deletion, security, notice, or reporting.
  • It does not create a process for complaints, investigations, or decisions about whether an exception applies.
  • It does not say what consequence, if any, applies when a government entity violates its restriction.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it sets limits on handling data gathered through tools that can record vehicle locations and other observations.
  • The restrictions apply to both private persons and government entities, while preserving stated uses such as law enforcement work, toll billing, and traffic photo enforcement.
  • The limit on peace officers’ use of data beyond their duties, backed by a felony penalty, could discourage unauthorized handling.

Case against#

  • The exceptions for normal business and government activity are broad and undefined, which could make the main restriction difficult to apply consistently.
  • The bill does not set data-retention or deletion rules, or give people a way to learn about or challenge data use.
  • The bill creates a felony penalty for private persons and peace officers but does not state a penalty for government entities that violate the restriction.