Surveillance data restricted for one year

Summary#

HB 1011, the “1984 No More Act,” would add three sections to Ohio’s Revised Code; it is an introduced bill, not law, and passage is uncertain. For one year after its effective date, it would restrict access to and handling of data from automated license plate recognition systems and mass surveillance technology, with exceptions. Its stated goal is to protect the public from intrusive government surveillance.

  • Government entities and private persons would be barred from knowingly accessing, collecting, using, selling, transferring, or sharing captured surveillance data, unless an exception applies.
  • The restrictions would cover data from systems such as license-plate cameras, facial recognition, and gait recognition. The bill defines an exception for a camera used only to monitor a specific area for immediate security, without an identification database or analytics system.
  • Law enforcement could use or share the data for listed alert programs and to aid federal immigration officials in identifying and locating a person who lacks legal presence in the United States.
  • Toll operators could use camera data only for toll billing, subject to other listed legal requirements, and could not integrate it with a law-enforcement database or make it accessible to law enforcement without a warrant. Traffic-law photo-monitoring devices are also exempt.
  • The bill would set statewide rules that limit conflicting local rules. The new sections would be repealed one year after the act’s effective date.

What it means for you#

  • Private people and businesses: You could not knowingly access, collect, use, sell, transfer, or share covered data unless an exception applies. The bill does not expressly ban owning or operating the technology as such, but collecting data from it is prohibited.
  • Government agencies and law enforcement: The same restrictions would apply, with the listed exceptions. A peace officer could not handle the data beyond the officer’s duties or the permitted purposes.
  • Local governments: You could not enact or keep rules that conflict with or preempt state policy on these technologies and data.
  • Drivers and other members of the public: The bill does not create a stated process to request or delete data, a private right to sue, or a new service. It also does not say what happens to data gathered before the restrictions take effect.
  • Toll-road users: Toll operators could continue using camera data for toll billing only under the bill’s conditions.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not state a public spending amount, funding source, fee, fine, or staffing requirement.
  • It does not estimate costs for agencies, businesses, or toll operators to comply.

What is unclear#

  • The bill’s effective date is not stated in the supplied text. Its restrictions would end when the new sections are repealed one year after that date.
  • The bill does not set out enforcement, penalties, remedies, or an oversight process.
  • It does not explain how data already held would be handled, or what rules would apply after repeal.
  • Terms such as “mass surveillance technology” and “immediate security purposes” may leave uncertainty about which systems and uses are covered.
  • The supplied material does not include the current text of the Revised Code sections being enacted. I could not verify how the bill would interact with current Ohio law or how much would differ from existing law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to limit the collection and use of detailed information about people’s movements and activities, including by government entities and private persons.
  • A possible argument for statewide rules is that they would set the same restrictions across Ohio rather than leaving conflicting local rules in place.
  • The bill allows specified emergency-alert uses and limited toll billing, so it does not impose a complete bar on all uses of this data.

Case against#

  • The restrictions last only one year before the new sections are repealed. That could make the rules temporary without explaining what protections follow.
  • The bill allows law enforcement to use data to aid federal immigration officials in locating a person who lacks legal presence in the United States, while broadly restricting other uses.
  • The bill does not explain how violations would be detected or addressed, or how affected people could challenge data use.
  • The definitions and broad limits could leave agencies and businesses uncertain about which data and activities are prohibited.