Family Sovereignty Act limits non-parent custody

Summary#

House Bill 1013, called the Family Sovereignty Act, would amend six Ohio Revised Code sections and add a new one. It would limit some non-parent custody cases involving married parents who are maintaining a family unit. The bill says it aims to protect that unit; it is introduced and is not law.

  • Juvenile and domestic-relations courts generally could not decide custody in a case started or continued by a non-parent when the parents are married to each other and maintaining a family unit.
  • Some custody and support matters involving married parents would go to domestic-relations court. A juvenile court could transfer certain cases there with the receiving court’s consent; it would have to transfer cases connected to a pending divorce or similar action between the parents.
  • A new section says a non-parent may not start a custody or support case about a child in a maintained family unit, except when the case is connected to an action between the parents. The supplied text cuts off before the section’s full wording.
  • The bill’s title says it would limit who may file abuse, neglect, or dependency complaints. But the legible complaint provision still says any person with knowledge may file such a complaint, while also expressly allowing public and private child-placement agencies to file. The supplied text does not resolve this conflict.

What it means for you#

  • Parents who are married and maintaining a family unit: A non-parent could face limits on starting or continuing a court case to obtain custody or support for the child. The bill does not define “maintaining a family unit.”
  • Non-parent relatives or caregivers: The proposed limit could make it harder to seek a custody or support order in the covered circumstances.
  • People reporting abuse, neglect, or dependency: The bill’s stated purpose is to narrow who may file complaints, but the complaint language provided appears to allow any person with knowledge to file. The exact effect is unclear.
  • Courts: The bill would change which court handles some cases and set rules for transferring cases between juvenile and domestic-relations courts.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s estimated cost.

  • The supplied text includes no appropriation or cost estimate.
  • It changes court jurisdiction and transfer rules, but does not state what added court or agency work would cost.

What is unclear#

  • The current versions of the amended Ohio laws were not supplied, so the exact changes from current law could not be verified.
  • The bill text is truncated, and its complaint-filing provision appears to conflict with its stated aim of limiting who may file abuse, neglect, or dependency complaints.
  • “Maintaining a family unit” is not defined in the supplied text.
  • The new section’s full wording and any further exceptions are unavailable.
  • The bill does not specify how courts should decide whether a family unit is being maintained.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to protect the custody role of married parents who are maintaining a family unit.
  • A possible argument for the approach is that it would keep non-parent custody disputes out of court in those circumstances.
  • Directing some family cases to domestic-relations court and setting transfer rules could make court responsibility clearer.

Case against#

  • Limits on non-parent custody or support cases could leave relatives or caregivers with fewer ways to ask a court for an order in the covered circumstances.
  • It is unclear how a court would decide whether parents and a child are “maintaining a family unit.”
  • The bill’s stated restriction on abuse, neglect, and dependency complaints is not clearly reflected in the complaint language provided. That uncertainty could affect families, agencies, and courts.
  • No estimate is provided for the court or agency costs of changing jurisdiction and transferring cases.