Outage credits would reimburse customers

Summary#

HB 1014 would create new sections of Ohio’s Revised Code; it does not amend an existing Act in the supplied text. Its stated goal is to require bill credits and reimbursements after certain power outages. It is introduced, not law, and the text gives no start date.

  • Electric distribution utilities would have to credit customers if service is not restored within 16 hours in normal conditions, 36 hours in “gray sky” conditions, or 72 hours in catastrophic conditions. These categories depend mainly on the share of a utility’s customers with sustained interruptions; a state of emergency can also qualify as catastrophic.
  • A residential customer’s credit would be at least $50 or the customer’s monthly utility charge, whichever is higher, with additional credits for each further 24 hours without service. A customer with six or more sustained interruptions in 12 months would receive one credit, and the count would reset.
  • Nonresidential customers would receive a credit based on their minimum bill, prorated for the days they were out of service. Credits must be applied within 90 days after the interruption ends, with any remaining amount carried forward.
  • Utilities would have to provide affected residential customers a form to claim reimbursement for food or refrigerated prescription medicine spoiled because of an outage. The bill sets different amounts based on whether customers provide a list or proof of losses.
  • Utilities could ask the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio (PUCO) to waive these requirements. The commission would decide based on factors including whether the event was outside the utility’s control and whether the utility maintained the system adequately.

What it means for you#

  • Residential customers: If the outage and restoration-time rules apply, you would receive a bill credit. You could also claim reimbursement for spoiled food or refrigerated prescription medicine. For food, a self-certified itemized list allows a claim up to $250; proof of actual losses allows up to $600. Documented losses for refrigerated prescription medicine are reimbursed at the documented amount.
  • Nonresidential customers: You would receive a credit calculated from your minimum bill and the number of days service was out, if the bill’s conditions are met.
  • Electric customers: Utilities could not recover the costs of these credits and reimbursements from their customers.
  • Utilities: They would have to provide credits and claim forms, and would pay approved reimbursements unless PUCO grants a waiver.
  • The public: The bill does not require utilities to restore service by the stated deadlines; it requires credits when those deadlines are missed.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • Utilities would pay for required credits and reimbursements, and could not recover those costs from customers.
  • The bill does not state a public funding amount or estimate PUCO’s costs for making rules and deciding waiver petitions.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not give a start date. Its passage is uncertain because it is introduced.
  • The text does not explain how an outage would be classified if more than one condition applies, or how the customer-share thresholds would be measured.
  • The bill requires PUCO to adopt rules, but does not set out claim forms, proof standards, payment timelines for reimbursements, or an appeal process for denied claims.
  • The annual credit adjustment uses the difference between two October consumer price index values, but does not explain how that difference is meant to calculate an inflation adjustment.
  • The supplied material does not describe existing outage compensation rules. No publicly available information.
  • The text does not explain how “minimum bill” or “monthly utility charge” is determined for these calculations.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that customers would receive a set credit when outages last beyond stated limits, rather than bearing the full cost of a prolonged loss of service.
  • Reimbursement claims address a specific harm: food and refrigerated prescription medicine spoiled because of an outage.
  • The waiver process could allow PUCO to excuse utilities when conditions were outside their reasonable control, while also considering maintenance and emergency response.
  • The bill bars utilities from passing these costs on to customers, so the compensation would not be funded through a charge to other customers.

Case against#

  • One concern is that utilities would bear costs that could vary with outage length and the number of claims, while the bill provides no estimate of those costs.
  • The bill does not explain how reimbursement claims would be checked or appealed, which could leave important parts of the process to later rules.
  • The outage categories and annual credit adjustment may be difficult to apply consistently without clearer instructions.
  • The bill provides compensation for missed restoration deadlines but does not require utilities to restore service by those deadlines or otherwise set new repair duties.