Plant-Closure Settlements Could Be Barred

Summary#

Ohio HB 1041, “Regards settlements to close electric generating facilities,” would amend Ohio Revised Code section 4905.23 and add three sections. It would bar certain settlement agreements to close generating plants and, in some cases, require a facility to keep operating despite a settlement. Its stated goal is to protect electricity supply and grid reliability; that goal is not a guaranteed result.

  • A “settlement” is an agreement between parties to a state court or state regulatory proceeding, where the parties are not state agencies. The bill would bar anyone from entering such a settlement to close a base-load facility or a generating plant owned or operated by a public utility.
  • A base-load facility is defined as an Ohio plant that primarily uses nonrenewable fuel, including coal, natural gas, or nuclear reaction. The definition excludes facilities owned or operated by a public utility, municipal corporation, or electric cooperative.
  • A person covered by a settlement to close a base-load facility would have to keep operating it if a listed organization or government body orders or requests continued operation for grid reliability or resource adequacy. Operation could continue only as long as necessary for that purpose.
  • The bill would not require an owner or operator to reopen a facility already shut down, and would not prevent closure for a reason other than a settlement.

What it means for you#

  • Owners and operators of base-load facilities: A settlement to close a facility could be barred. If a covered settlement exists and a listed body orders or requests continued operation, the facility must keep operating for the period needed for reliability or resource adequacy. The bill does not require reopening a facility that has already shut down.
  • Public utilities and parties to proceedings: The settlement ban also covers agreements to close a generating plant owned or operated by a public utility. That category is separate from the bill’s definition of a base-load facility.
  • Electricity customers: The bill states a goal of protecting customers and maintaining reliable supply. It does not guarantee that customers will avoid negative effects or that supply will be adequate.
  • General public: The bill is introduced and is not law. It does not set an effective date in the supplied text.

Money#

The bill requires continued operation in some cases, but the available material gives no cost estimate.

  • It does not state who would pay the costs of continued operation, or provide a funding or compensation mechanism.
  • No appropriation, fee, tax, or fine is set out in the supplied bill text.
  • No publicly available information on staffing, public costs, or savings is included in the supplied material.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of Ohio Revised Code section 4905.23 was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify how much of the amended section is new.
  • The bill does not explain how disputes about whether continued operation is “necessary” would be resolved, or set a review or appeal process.
  • It does not explain how operating costs would be recovered or who would bear them.
  • The supplied text does not specify an enforcement process or penalty for violating the settlement ban. Current-law consequences could not be checked without the existing law.
  • The bill does not set a start date.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a settlement should not prevent continued generation when a listed body determines it is needed for grid reliability or resource adequacy.
  • Limiting required operation to the period needed for those purposes could offer a temporary response rather than requiring a facility to operate indefinitely.
  • The bill’s policy statements identify reliable electricity supplies and avoiding negative customer impacts as goals.

Case against#

  • The settlement ban applies broadly to agreements to close covered plants, even when no order or request to keep operating has been made.
  • A required extension of operations could impose costs on an owner or operator, but the bill does not say who pays or how those costs are handled.
  • The bill does not set out a process to resolve disagreements about the need for continued operation or how long it is necessary.
  • It is unclear how the settlement ban would interact with existing law or proceedings; the current version of the amended section was not supplied.