In-home appliance sales ban

Summary#

Bill 14, the Door-to-Door Sales Prohibition Act, 2016, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to prohibit in-person sales, leases and rentals of certain products at a consumer’s home.

  • It would prohibit selling, leasing, renting or offering to do so at a consumer’s home for air conditioners, water heaters, furnaces, water treatment devices and any other products later prescribed by regulation. It would also prohibit causing someone else to do these things.
  • The Minister of Government and Consumer Services would administer the Act and could make regulations, including adding products, exempting people or classes of people, and setting rules for consumer payments.
  • A contract made because of a violation would be void. The seller would have to repay the consumer and cover certain reasonable costs, as set out in regulations.
  • A consumer who did not receive payment could sue in the Superior Court of Justice. If successful, the consumer would generally be entitled to twice the money paid, plus eligible costs, unless the court found that result inequitable.
  • Violations would be offences, with maximum fines that rise for repeat offences: for individuals, $500, $1,000, then $2,000; for corporations, $5,000, $10,000, then $25,000.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers: If you buy, lease or rent a listed product through a sale that violates the ban, the contract would be void. You would be entitled to repayment and certain reasonable costs, including costs of uninstalling and returning the product and, where applicable, getting and installing a replacement. You would not owe charges or penalties under the void contract or a related agreement.
  • Consumers who invite a seller: The exception applies to a consumer who invites someone into their home, but only for the rule against causing another person to make the sale. The invited seller would still be prohibited from selling, leasing, renting or offering a listed product in the home.
  • Sellers and businesses: They would have to stop covered in-person sales, leases and rentals at consumers’ homes, including offers and arrangements where they cause someone else to do it. A violation could also make the resulting contract void and require repayment and cost payments.
  • Consumers and sellers: The bill says it would not restrict advertising and marketing activities, or other activities later prescribed by regulation. It does not set out a process for reporting violations or deciding complaints.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the supplied material.

  • Sellers could owe refunds and eligible consumer costs; a successful court action could result in an order for twice the money paid, plus eligible costs.
  • The bill sets maximum fines for individuals and corporations but does not estimate how many fines might be imposed or how much revenue they could raise.
  • The bill assigns administration to the Minister but gives no estimate for government staffing or other public costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “at the consumer’s home” or set out how to decide whether a particular sale was made there.
  • Regulations would govern payments to consumers, but the bill itself does not set payment deadlines or explain how consumers would obtain refunds without suing.
  • The bill allows regulations to add products, exempt people or classes of people, and identify other activities not restricted. Those rules are not included in the supplied text.
  • The text does not identify who would enforce the offence provisions or how suspected violations would be investigated.
  • No publicly available information in the supplied material says whether Bill 14 passed. If enacted, it would come into force two months after Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • A ban could protect consumers from in-person sales of the listed products at home, while void contracts and repayment rules would give consumers a remedy if a prohibited sale occurred.
  • The bill covers both sellers and people or businesses that cause someone else to make a covered sale, which could prevent the ban from being avoided by using another seller.
  • Keeping advertising and marketing activities outside the ban could allow businesses to promote products without making the prohibited in-home sale.

Case against#

  • The ban would apply to the seller even when the consumer invited that person into the home. This could limit consumers’ choice to arrange an in-home sale for a listed product.
  • The bill does not explain how a consumer should obtain repayment without going to court, or how violations would be enforced.
  • The Minister could add products and create exemptions through regulations, but the bill does not set criteria for those decisions or explain how affected consumers and businesses would be consulted.