Summary#
Bill 27, Stop the Calls Act, 2018, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to stop unsolicited sales and advertising calls about products or services set out in regulations.
- A caller could not make, or cause someone else to make, a covered call to a consumer without advance consent from someone in the consumer’s household. The caller would have to prove consent.
- The ban would apply only to products or services prescribed by regulation. The bill also allows the Minister to exempt people or classes of people by regulation.
- Calls by or for named charities, not-for-profit corporations and political groups would be exempt. So would calls to people with a defined existing business relationship with the caller or organization.
- A contract resulting from a prohibited call would be void. The consumer could be entitled to a refund and certain reasonable costs, and would not be liable for obligations or charges under the contract or a related agreement.
- The Minister of Government and Consumer Services would administer the Act. A person convicted of breaking the ban could face escalating fines: up to $500 for an individual or $5,000 for a corporation on a first offence, rising to $2,000 or $25,000 for a third or later offence.
What it means for you#
- Consumers: If the bill became law, you could still receive calls about products or services not prescribed by regulation, or calls covered by an exception. For a covered call, someone in your household would need to have consented in advance. Consent could be oral, written or shown through another affirmative action, but could not be obtained through an unsolicited call.
- Consumers with a resulting contract: The contract would be void even if you had already paid or received the product or service. The provider would have to repay your money and, where applicable, reasonable costs to uninstall and return the product and obtain and install a replacement. If you did not receive payment, you could sue in the Superior Court of Justice. If successful, the court would generally order twice the money paid under the contract, plus the applicable costs, unless that would be inequitable. If you were awarded legal costs, you could also recover additional actual legal costs incurred in obtaining the order.
- Callers and businesses: They would have to avoid prohibited calls or ensure valid prior consent, and keep in mind that they would bear the burden of proving consent. Breaking the ban could lead to a fine after conviction.
- People receiving calls from exempt organizations or existing business contacts: The bill would not ban those calls under this provision. Its existing-business-relationship exception includes certain purchases in the previous 18 months, inquiries in the previous six months, and current or recently expired written contracts.
Money#
No cost estimate or public spending figure is provided in the supplied material.
- The bill would require providers to make refunds and, where applicable, pay specified reasonable costs when a contract is void.
- A consumer who sued successfully could generally recover twice the amount paid under the contract, plus applicable costs; additional actual legal costs could also be recovered if the consumer received an award of legal costs.
- The bill sets maximum fines, but gives no estimate of how many fines or payments might result. It also does not provide a cost estimate for administering or enforcing the Act.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not list which products or services would be covered. The Minister may prescribe them by regulation.
- The bill does not specify how or when providers must make refunds and pay costs; it leaves payment rules to regulations.
- It does not name who would investigate or prosecute offences, or set out an investigation, complaint or appeal process.
- Terms such as “reasonable costs” and when it would be “inequitable” to order the usual court remedy are not defined in the bill.
- The supplied material does not establish whether this bill became law or whether regulations were made. The text says it would start two months after Royal Assent.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to give consumers more control over sales calls by requiring advance consent for calls about covered products or services.
- Putting the burden of proving consent on the caller could make the consent rule more enforceable for consumers.
- Making resulting contracts void, with refund rights and protection from related charges, could give consumers a remedy beyond simply refusing a call.
- The listed exceptions preserve calls from specified charitable, not-for-profit and political organizations, as well as certain existing business contacts.
Case against#
- The ban’s reach would depend on which products and services the Minister prescribed, and the bill does not set limits on that choice.
- The Minister could exempt people or classes of people by regulation, subject to conditions or restrictions. The bill does not specify which exemptions might be made.
- The bill does not set out how consumers would report calls or how offences would be investigated and enforced.
- A consumer might need to sue to obtain payment if a provider did not pay. The bill does not explain how often that might happen or what other routes to payment would be available.