Stop Unsolicited Calls Act

Summary#

Bill 137, Stop the Calls Act, 2017, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend another Act. Its stated goal is to stop certain unsolicited sales and advertising calls by banning them for products or services prescribed in regulations.

  • The ban would apply to calls to consumers (people acting for personal, family or household purposes) when no one in their household gave advance consent about that product or service. The caller would have to prove consent.
  • The ban would not cover calls for products or services that are not prescribed, and it would have exceptions for charities, not-for-profit corporations, specified political callers and people or organizations with certain existing business relationships.
  • A person who made, or caused someone to make, a prohibited call could face a fine: up to $500 for an individual or $5,000 for a corporation for a first offence, with higher maximums for later offences.
  • A contract resulting from a prohibited call would be void. The consumer would be owed money paid and, if applicable, reasonable costs for removing and returning the product and obtaining and installing a replacement.
  • If the consumer had to sue to recover those amounts and won, the court would generally order twice the money paid under the contract, plus applicable costs. The court could decide not to award this if it would be inequitable.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers: If a prohibited call led to a contract, you would not be liable for obligations or charges under it or a related agreement. You could sue in the Superior Court of Justice if the required payment was not made.
  • Businesses and callers: You would need advance consent from someone in the consumer’s household for calls covered by the ban. Consent could be oral, written or another affirmative action, but it could not be obtained through an unsolicited call. The bill does not ban all sales or advertising calls.
  • Charities, not-for-profit corporations and specified political callers: Calls made by or for these groups would be exempt from the ban.
  • The responsible Minister: The Minister of Government and Consumer Services would administer the Act and could make regulations, including choosing which products or services the ban covers.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated public cost is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill would require payment to consumers for covered void contracts, but the number or value of payments is unknown.
  • It allows consumers to seek court orders, including for twice the money paid and certain costs, but gives no estimate of likely claims or awards.
  • It sets maximum fines but does not say how much fine revenue, if any, would be collected.
  • The bill does not provide a staffing or enforcement budget.

What is unclear#

  • Which products or services would be prescribed—and therefore covered—is left to regulations.
  • The bill does not set out how consumers would request refunds or how payment disputes would be handled. It leaves payment rules to regulations.
  • It does not name who would investigate or prosecute offences.
  • It does not explain how the new law would interact with existing protections or call rules. No current-law material was supplied for comparison.
  • The text says the Act would start two months after Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not say whether or when it received Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give consumers a way to reject unsolicited calls about specified products and services, with the caller responsible for proving consent.
  • Making a resulting contract void and requiring repayment could give consumers a direct remedy when a prohibited call leads to a purchase.
  • Exemptions for listed charities, political callers and certain existing business relationships would limit the ban’s reach.

Case against#

  • The bill does not itself identify the products or services covered. The Minister could also make regulations exempting people or classes of people, subject to conditions or restrictions.
  • The bill gives a consumer strong financial remedies, including potentially twice the money paid, but does not spell out a refund process or how a dispute would be resolved without going to court.
  • The ban’s coverage depends on who in a household gave consent and on the caller proving it; the bill does not set out how that proof would be recorded or assessed.