Summary#
Bill 148, the Fair Workplaces, Better Jobs Act, 2017, became law as Chapter 22 of Ontario’s 2017 statutes. It amended the Employment Standards Act, 2000, the Labour Relations Act, 1995, and the Occupational Health and Safety Act, with related amendments to other Acts. Its stated goal was to improve workplace standards and jobs.
- Employers became subject to new rules on minimum wages, scheduling, equal pay, vacation, public holidays, and employee leaves.
- The Labour Relations Board gained new certification and bargaining-unit powers, and the law added protections for some employees during union certification, bargaining, strikes, and lockouts.
- Employers gained new obligations to provide records and pay amounts owing; employment standards officers and the Director gained stronger collection and public-disclosure powers.
- Employers generally cannot require workers to wear elevated-heel footwear unless it is needed for safe work; an exception applies to performers in the entertainment and advertising industry.
- This summary describes the 2017 law. The parent Acts and later amendments were not supplied, so current law could not be verified.
What it means for you#
- Employees: From January 1, 2018, the general minimum wage was set at $14 an hour, rising to $15 on January 1, 2019, then subject to annual inflation adjustments from October 2019. Different rates applied to some students, liquor servers who regularly received tips, homeworkers, and hunting and fishing guides.
- Employees: Employers had to pay at least three hours’ wages in certain short-shift and on-call situations, and for shifts cancelled with less than 48 hours’ notice. Employees could refuse certain unscheduled work or on-call requests made with less than 96 hours’ notice. Exceptions applied, including for emergencies and essential public services.
- Employees: The law created equal-pay rules for employees doing substantially the same work despite different employment status, and for temporary-agency assignment employees compared with the client’s employees. It also protected certain pay discussions and inquiries from reprisals.
- Employees: Employees with at least five years’ service became entitled to at least three weeks’ vacation. The law also expanded several unpaid leaves and created paid leave entitlements: two personal-emergency days a year after one week of employment, and up to five paid domestic- or sexual-violence leave days a year after 13 consecutive weeks of employment.
- Temporary help agencies: Agencies had to give one week’s written notice or pay when qualifying assignments estimated to last at least three months ended early, unless an exception applied.
- Unions and employers: In three named industries—building services, home care and community services, and temporary help agencies—unions could choose a certification process that could result in certification without a vote when membership exceeded 55%; between 40% and 55%, a vote was required. The Board also gained powers to order employee lists in specified circumstances and to review some bargaining-unit structures.
- Workers and the public: The law did not create a general new benefit program or change taxes. The footwear rule did not apply to performers in the named industry.
Money#
No total cost estimate is provided in the available material.
- Employers may face higher wage, leave, vacation, scheduling, record-keeping, and assignment-termination costs.
- The law requires public agencies to carry out new enforcement and labour-relations functions, but provides no staffing or cost estimate here.
- Some mediation-arbitration costs are shared by the parties or set by regulation; no overall amount is stated.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not show later changes to the Acts. It cannot establish which 2017 rules remain in force today.
- Some details depend on regulations, including penalties, exceptions, and definitions of industries or eligible groups.
- The text does not provide an overall estimate of employer compliance costs or government administration costs.
- The law sets duties and powers, but the supplied material does not show how often they were used or their results.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to set a wage floor and improve predictability and pay for workers with short shifts, changing schedules, or temporary assignments.
- Equal-pay rules could address pay differences tied to employment status when work and working conditions are substantially the same.
- Broader leave rights could give employees more protected time to deal with serious illness, family needs, or domestic or sexual violence.
- New union procedures and bargaining protections could make it easier for some workers to organize and negotiate a first agreement.
Case against#
- Higher minimum wages and paid-leave requirements could raise costs for employers; the supplied material does not quantify those costs or their effects.
- Scheduling rules have exceptions and leave room for regulations, so their practical reach depends partly on details outside the bill text.
- The Board’s new powers over certification and bargaining-unit structure could change how employers and unions organize bargaining, while some decisions may be made without a hearing.
- The bill creates many new rules and enforcement powers, but the supplied material does not give a total public cost or explain how outcomes would be measured.