Summary#
Bill 47, the Making Ontario Open for Business Act, 2018, was enacted as Chapter 14 of Ontario’s 2018 statutes. It amends the Employment Standards Act, 2000, the Labour Relations Act, 1995, and the Ontario College of Trades and Apprenticeship Act, 2009, with related changes to other Acts. Its title presents a goal of making Ontario more open for business; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result.
- Employees and employers: The bill sets minimum pay for some short shifts, replaces personal emergency leave with separate unpaid sick, family responsibility and bereavement leaves, and removes the minimum-wage increase that had been set for January 1, 2019.
- Unions and employers: It removes some union certification routes and bargaining supports, changes when the Labour Relations Board may certify a union, and creates a new process for arbitration of a first collective agreement.
- Apprentices and trades: For trades subject to a ratio, the bill sets a limit of one apprentice per journeyperson, unless a regulation sets a different ratio or an exemption process applies.
- Ontario College of Trades: The Minister gains powers to end appointments, dissolve boards and committees, and exercise some appointment powers. A regulation may also give the Minister control over the Board’s affairs, including financial matters and College assets.
- Public and trade unions: The Minister must make filed collective agreements available to the public. The bill also lowers maximum fines for Labour Relations Act offences.
What it means for you#
- Employees: If you regularly work more than three hours a day but are required to report and work less than three hours, your employer must pay at least three hours’ wages, subject to an exception for events beyond the employer’s control that stop work.
- Employees: After at least two consecutive weeks with an employer, you are entitled to up to three unpaid sick-leave days, three unpaid family-responsibility-leave days and two unpaid bereavement-leave days per calendar year. Employers may ask for evidence that is reasonable in the circumstances. Taking part of a day may count as a full day.
- Employees: The new family-responsibility and bereavement leaves cover listed family members, including a relative who depends on you for care or assistance. The bill repeals personal emergency leave and says the new leave entitlements apply separately and in addition to each other.
- Employees and employers: The bill changes the formula for calculating public-holiday pay. It also removes the increase to minimum wage set for January 1, 2019, and provides for annual inflation adjustments starting October 1, 2020.
- Unions and employers: For certain employer violations, the Board may order a vote, another vote, or—if no other remedy would be sufficient—certify a union. After a direction for first-agreement arbitration, strikes and lockouts are barred; if one is underway, it must end and employees must be reinstated, subject to the bill’s conditions.
- Apprentices, trades and the College: The Minister may end appointments without notice or cause and dissolve specified College boards and committees. Separate control over the Board’s affairs requires a regulation. The Act’s repeal also requires a proclamation; it did not happen automatically on Royal Assent.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill requires parties to pay for some first-agreement arbitrations; the amount for arbitration by the Board is to be set by regulation.
- If a regulation gives the Minister control over the Board’s affairs, the College must pay expenses the Minister incurs to the extent the Minister directs. The bill does not estimate those expenses.
- The bill lowers the maximum Labour Relations Act fine from $5,000 to $2,000 for individuals and from $100,000 to $25,000 for corporations.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the amended Acts in consolidated form, so I cannot verify the law in force now or account for later changes.
- The materials do not give the cost of implementing the changes, including staffing, arbitration or any Minister-led control of the College.
- The bill allows regulations to set different apprentice ratios, exemptions and conditions, but the supplied material does not say what those rules are.
- The bill does not set out how the Minister would use the College powers, or when the College Act’s repeal would be proclaimed.
- The materials do not explain how the new leave rules compare in practice with the full previous personal emergency leave entitlement.
Case for#
- A minimum payment for some very short shifts may protect employees who report for work but receive little work.
- Separate leave entitlements make the listed reasons for leave and their annual limits explicit.
- First-agreement arbitration gives the Board a way to settle a first contract when bargaining has failed for reasons listed in the Act.
- Making collective agreements public may improve access to information about negotiated terms.
- A common apprentice-to-journeyperson ratio may provide a clear baseline for trades covered by the rule.
Case against#
- The new statutory leaves are unpaid and capped; employees may have limited time off for illness, family needs or bereavement.
- Removing union access to employee lists and some certification routes may make organizing harder. The bill also removes bargaining-unit review and educational support provisions.
- The Board may certify a union without another vote in certain cases, which is a significant remedy that can affect employees and employers.
- The lower maximum fines may reduce the consequences for Labour Relations Act offences.
- The Minister’s powers over the College—including possible control of finances and assets—are broad, while the supplied material does not set out detailed safeguards or oversight.