Red-tape cutting bill speeds business filings

Summary#

Bill 154, the Cutting Unnecessary Red Tape Act, 2017, was enacted as Chapter 20 of Ontario’s 2017 statutes. It amends or repeals many existing Acts and creates the Reducing Regulatory Costs for Business Act, 2017. Its stated goal is to reduce unnecessary red tape while protecting the public interest.

  • Business regulation: When a regulation covered by the new Act creates or increases prescribed administrative costs for businesses, an offset must be made within a prescribed time. In certain prescribed cases, the government must also assess and publish the regulation’s potential impact.
  • Trusts and charities: A trustee may use trust property for a “social investment” that directly furthers the trust’s purposes and achieves a financial return. Trustees must assess the trust’s interests, consider whether to get advice, and review investments over time. The trust’s terms may restrict or exclude this power, but not those duties.
  • Corporate and non-profit filings: The bill changes how many corporate laws handle electronic filing, records and searches. It gives Directors or Registrars powers to set filing, form, signature, technology and search requirements, and to delegate duties or make agreements with service providers.
  • Other business rules: The bill changes franchise-law coverage and exemptions, and allows Ontario to collect and share prescribed business information under certain agreements. It also changes pesticide licensing and permit rules.
  • Courts, juries and elections: It creates a complaint process for the Small Claims Court Administrative Judge; allows jurors to return questionnaires electronically and gives them 30 days to do so; and lets municipal election compliance audit committees deliberate in private.
  • The bill also repeals the Employers and Employees Act and makes changes to many other laws, including rules for notaries, corporate shareholder proposals and non-profit corporations. Different provisions have different start dates.

What it means for you#

  • Businesses: If a regulation requires documents to be sent to an Ontario ministry, a business may choose to submit them electronically. Ministries must develop plans to recognize businesses with excellent compliance records. Less onerous rules for small businesses and use of recognized standards are required where appropriate.
  • Businesses providing information to government: If an agreement is in place, a minister may require prescribed business information, such as contact details. Information may be centralized by the province and shared with the federal government; some sharing rules can override confidentiality provisions in other laws.
  • Trustees and charities: Trustees gain permission to make qualifying social investments, unless the trust terms restrict or exclude that power. They must still meet the bill’s duties, including reviewing the investments over time.
  • Companies and non-profits: Filing and record processes may become electronic. Some corporate filing services may be provided by outside organizations under agreements with the government. The bill allows those agreements to cover the use, disclosure, sale or licensing of records and information.
  • Shareholders: For a proposal to be put to shareholders, companies may be exempt from circulating it if it arrives too late or if a substantially similar proposal failed to meet support thresholds at earlier meetings. For offering corporations, the deadline is 60 days; for other corporations, it is set by corporate documents or defaults to 21 to 60 days.
  • Jurors and people involved in municipal election audits: Jurors get 30 days to return a questionnaire, and may use an electronic method specified on it. A sheriff may send a summons electronically if the person consented. Audit committees may deliberate in private, though their meetings must be open to the public.
  • The general public: The bill does not create a general business grant or change tax rates. It changes laws and administrative powers across many subjects.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The business-cost offset rule requires an offset when covered regulations add or increase prescribed administrative costs, but the bill leaves the method and timing to regulations.
  • The bill gives existing government offices new filing, staffing, information and administration duties, but no staffing or cost estimate is provided.
  • It allows fees for some corporate filing and search services to be set by ministerial order; the material does not give fee amounts or say which new fees will be charged.

What is unclear#

  • Many important details depend on regulations or requirements set later, including what counts as an administrative cost, how offsets are calculated, and when impact analyses are required.
  • The bill does not specify the content of business-information rules, how long information is kept, or what privacy safeguards apply.
  • It does not say how government will decide whether lighter small-business rules, recognized standards or compliance recognition are appropriate.
  • Commencement varies by provision, and some changes require a proclamation. The available material does not establish which provisions are in force now.
  • The parent Acts were not supplied, so current-law differences and the full effect of some amendments could not be independently verified.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to reduce business paperwork and make government interactions more digital.
  • Requiring an offset for new or increased administrative costs could encourage rule-makers to consider those costs when designing regulations.
  • Social-investment powers give trustees flexibility to pursue a financial return while furthering a trust’s purpose, with duties to assess and review those investments.
  • Changes to corporate filing and jury questionnaires may allow more electronic handling of documents.

Case against#

  • The offset rule depends on later regulations, and the bill says a regulation is not invalid merely because the Act’s requirements were not followed. That may limit how much protection the rule gives businesses.
  • Directors and Registrars receive broad powers to set filing and related requirements outside the ordinary regulation-making process; the bill does not spell out the oversight for those requirements.
  • Business information may be centralized and shared, including with the federal government, without detailed privacy rules in the bill.
  • The bill shortens the time for pesticide permit applicants to make submissions for reconsideration from 15 days to seven, which may leave less time to respond.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2017100301

    Passed95 members voted

    Motion for closure on Second Reading of Bill 154

    FOR · 52AGAINST · 43

    52For

    • Liberal52

    43Against

    • PC27
    • NDP16
  2. Division No. 2017100302

    Passed95 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 154

    FOR · 95

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    95For

    • Liberal52
    • PC27
    • NDP16

    0Against