Abortion Access Zones Bill

Summary#

Bill 163, the Protecting a Woman’s Right to Access Abortion Services Act, 2017, was enacted. It creates the Safe Access to Abortion Services Act, 2017 and amends Ontario’s Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act (FIPPA). Its stated goal is to protect the safety, security, health and privacy of people seeking or providing abortion services.

  • It bans specified conduct in access zones around clinics, certain prescribed facilities and protected providers’ homes. Clinics get zones automatically; other facilities must be prescribed.
  • In clinic and facility zones, the bans include advising or informing people about abortion-related issues, acts of disapproval and persistent requests. They also cover observing, interfering with, intimidating or recording people when done to dissuade them from seeking or providing services. Regulations may add prohibited activities.
  • In home zones, it bans specified acts of disapproval, persistent requests and conduct such as observation, interference, intimidation or recording when done to dissuade a provider. A separate ban covers certain repeated following, observation, requests, threats and communications intended to dissuade providers, including outside zones.
  • It allows criminal penalties, damages claims, court injunctions and warrantless arrests in specified circumstances. A person cannot be convicted under the clinic/facility-zone or home-zone bans without knowing or having been told where the zone is.
  • It narrows FIPPA access to abortion-service information that could identify a person or facility, or whose disclosure could reasonably be expected to threaten someone’s health or safety or a facility’s or building’s security. Other statistical or related information remains subject to FIPPA if it does not meet those tests.

What it means for you#

  • People seeking abortion services: Specified conduct is prohibited within the applicable access zones. In clinic and facility zones, some bans on advising, informing, disapproval and persistent requests do not apply to a person’s work at the clinic or facility, or to an interaction with someone accompanying the person with their consent.
  • Protected service providers and their households: Home zones protect providers’ residences and include specified conduct aimed at providers or household members. Other listed harassment of providers is prohibited anywhere when done to dissuade them from providing services.
  • People communicating or protesting: The restrictions apply to particular conduct, not every discussion of abortion everywhere. But some communications and acts of disapproval are banned inside clinic and facility zones. Conviction can bring a fine or jail, or both; a person who suffers loss from a breach may also seek damages.
  • People seeking government records: FIPPA no longer applies to abortion-service information that meets the identification or safety/security tests. The amendment does not exclude all abortion-related statistics or information from FIPPA.
  • Public: The bill does not change abortion eligibility, create a medical service or impose a tax or fee. The Safe Access Act’s start date is to be set by proclamation; the supplied materials do not give that date. The FIPPA amendment took effect on Royal Assent.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The law authorizes fines and damages, but the materials do not estimate revenue or payments.
  • Enforcement and administration may require public resources, but no staffing or cost estimate is provided.

What is unclear#

  • The exact zones can vary: clinic zones generally extend 50 metres from the property, but regulations may set another distance up to 150 metres or different boundaries. Facility zones require regulations and cannot exceed 150 metres; home zones extend 150 metres unless regulations set a shorter distance.
  • The materials do not identify which facilities are prescribed, what additional activities may be prohibited, or whether regulations have been made.
  • “Act of disapproval” and some other terms are not defined in the supplied text.
  • The supplied materials do not give the proclamation date for the Safe Access Act, or details on how police, courts or affected people will apply the rules in particular cases.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to protect people seeking care and providers from interference, intimidation, unwanted recording and persistent approaches.
  • Fixed zones around service locations and providers’ homes could make the limits clearer than relying only on a general ban on harassment.
  • The law provides exceptions for some interactions with a person’s consent and for conduct done as part of work at the clinic or facility.
  • The FIPPA amendment protects identifiable or safety-sensitive information while keeping some statistical and other information subject to access rules.

Case against#

  • Some bans cover informing people about abortion-related issues or acts of disapproval within zones, even where the conduct is not described as threatening or physically interfering. This could restrict lawful expression near covered locations.
  • The bill gives regulations power to add prohibited activities and change zone boundaries, but the supplied text does not specify what those choices will be.
  • Criminal penalties, arrest powers and damages claims are significant enforcement tools; the text does not set out detailed procedures for deciding disputed cases.
  • The FIPPA safety and identification tests may keep some information from public access, and the materials do not explain how borderline cases will be decided.

Votes

2 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2017102501

    Passed87 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 163

    FOR · 86AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    86For

    • Liberal48
    • PC23
    • NDP15

    1Against

    • Independent1
  2. Division No. 2017101701

    Passed86 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 163

    FOR · 85AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    85For

    • Liberal47
    • PC23
    • NDP15

    1Against

    • Independent1