Summary#
Bill 168, the Putting Your Best Foot Forward Act, 2017, would amend Ontario’s Occupational Health and Safety Act. Its stated purpose is to prohibit employers from requiring footwear that is unsuitable for the protection needed at work or that prevents employees from working safely.
- Employers would be prohibited from requiring footwear that is not appropriate in design, construction and material for the protection the employee’s work requires.
- Employers would also be prohibited from requiring footwear that does not allow the employee to perform their work safely.
- The prohibition would apply 90 days after Royal Assent, if the bill became law.
What it means for you#
- Employees: Your employer could not require you to wear footwear that fails either of the bill’s tests. The bill does not say that employers must provide or pay for suitable footwear.
- Employers: You would have to ensure any footwear you require meets both the protection and safe-work tests.
- Others: The bill does not directly change footwear rules for people who are not employees or employers.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill does not set aside public money or set a fee.
- It does not require employers to pay for footwear or reimburse employees.
- Employers’ costs, if any, are not estimated.
What is unclear#
- “Appropriate” footwear and footwear that allows an employee to work “safely” are not defined.
- The bill does not set out a process for deciding whether footwear meets those tests, or how disputes would be handled.
- The supplied material does not include the existing Act, so the current footwear rules and how this prohibition would interact with them could not be verified.
- The material does not say whether Bill 168 passed or is in force.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to prevent employers from requiring footwear that is unsuitable for the work’s protective needs or makes safe work impossible.
- A possible argument for the bill is that footwear requirements should not conflict with the protection and safety employees need to do their jobs.
- The bill states two separate tests, covering both protective suitability and safe performance at work.
Case against#
- The bill does not define its key tests, so employers and employees may be uncertain about which footwear is allowed.
- It does not explain how disagreements would be resolved or what evidence would be used.
- A possible trade-off is that employers may have to change footwear requirements, but the bill does not address who would pay for any replacement footwear.