New rule to report unsafe door openings

Summary#

Bill 148, the Doored But Not Ignored Act, 2019, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act. Its stated goal is to improve the recording and reporting of incidents involving unsafe vehicle-door opening. The supplied material does not establish whether the bill became law.

  • Police officers and any persons later named by regulation would have to gather and promptly send the Registrar of Motor Vehicles information about a possible unsafe-door incident that caused an injury or property damage.
  • The Registrar would have to keep records of reported or otherwise obtained information about possible contraventions and include door-opening accidents in reports required under the Act.
  • The bill does not create a new offence or change the existing duty to take due precautions when opening a vehicle door. The supplied explanation describes that duty, but the current Act was not provided for comparison.

What it means for you#

  • Police and prescribed persons: If they know of a possible unsafe-door violation that caused injury or property damage, they would have to collect details about the incident and people involved, and send a written report to the Registrar without delay.
  • People involved in an incident: Their details may be collected for that report. The bill does not set out a process for making or appealing a decision that a violation occurred.
  • The Registrar: Would have to keep records and include door-opening accidents in reports under the Act.
  • People opening vehicle doors: The bill does not change the existing due-precautions duty or set a new penalty.
  • The public: The bill creates reporting and record-keeping duties, not a new public-facing service or a guarantee that every incident will be recorded.

Money#

The bill requires information-gathering and reporting work, but no cost estimate is provided.

  • Police, prescribed persons and the Registrar may need staff time and other resources; the bill gives no estimates.
  • It does not set a fee, fine, tax or funding amount.

What is unclear#

  • Regulations would identify who counts as a “prescribed person” and set the reporting forms. Those rules are not included.
  • The bill does not define “possible contravention” or explain what other information is necessary for a report.
  • The Registrar’s reporting format and schedule are not clear from the supplied text.
  • The bill does not explain how personal information would be handled or how the reporting system would be overseen.
  • The parent Act was not supplied, so the existing record-keeping and reporting requirements cannot be fully checked against the proposed changes.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make records of harmful unsafe-door incidents more complete.
  • Requiring reports from police and prescribed persons could give the Registrar information from more than one source.
  • Including door-opening accidents in the Registrar’s reports could make these incidents more visible in the information reported under the Act. This does not guarantee that every incident will be captured or that policy will change.

Case against#

  • A possible concern is that the bill requires collection of information about people involved but does not explain how that information will be protected or used.
  • The bill leaves key details—such as which additional people must report and what forms they must use—to later regulations.
  • Because the reporting duty applies when a person has knowledge of an incident, and only when injury or property damage resulted, the records may not capture every unsafe-door incident.
  • The bill creates work for police, prescribed persons and the Registrar without estimating the cost.