Municipal Workplace Integrity Bill

Summary#

Bill 207, the Municipal Accountability and Integrity Act, 2024, would amend Ontario’s Municipal Act, 2001 and City of Toronto Act, 2006. Its stated goal is to address councillor and local-board-member conduct, including workplace violence, harassment and discrimination. The parent Acts were not supplied, so I could not verify how these rules compare with current law.

  • Municipalities, local boards and Toronto would have to ensure members receive annual, mandatory training from a third-party provider on workplace violence, harassment and discrimination policies. Members who attend would have to attest in writing.
  • Codes of conduct would have to require members to follow those policies and report code-of-conduct violations.
  • The Minister would have to review the codes, create a framework covering required standards and processes, and set plans and schedules for implementing it. The framework must address training, penalties, investigations, timelines, reprisal protection, trauma-informed complaints, informal resolution and other listed matters.
  • The Minister would have to establish a Board of Integrity Commissioners within the existing Office of the Integrity Commissioner of Ontario. The Board’s role would be to adjudicate all claims about workplace violence, harassment and discrimination.
  • An Integrity Commissioner could seek a court’s confirmation of a finding about a member’s failure to follow workplace policies. If a judge finds the failure was egregious, the judge may vacate the member’s seat and bar them from standing for or being appointed to the same council or board until the second subsequent regular election. Toronto’s Commissioner would also have power to impose prescribed remedies and sanctions, which would be binding.

What it means for you#

  • Municipal and Toronto councillors and local-board members: You would have to follow the relevant workplace policies, report code-of-conduct violations and, if you attend the required training, submit written confirmation of attendance.
  • Municipalities, local boards and the City of Toronto: They would have to arrange the required training. The Minister would set implementation plans and schedules for the framework.
  • People affected by workplace conduct: A new Board within the Integrity Commissioner’s office would adjudicate claims about workplace violence, harassment and discrimination. The bill does not set out how to file a claim or how the Board would decide one.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The bill creates new duties and a Board, but does not itself create a general public service, benefit, tax or fee.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The bill requires annual third-party training and creates a Board, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The Minister would also have to review codes, develop the framework and establish implementation plans. The cost is not stated.
  • The bill gives no estimate of the cost of investigations, court applications or any prescribed penalties or remedies.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define key terms such as “egregiously,” or explain how the Board’s authority would relate to existing complaint or investigation processes.
  • It requires the Minister to create detailed rules later, but does not provide the rules, implementation dates or complaint procedures in the bill.
  • The bill does not say how many Board members there would be; that number is to be prescribed. It also does not define the “governing bodies” to consult on appointments.
  • The bill does not specify the penalties, remedies or sanctions that could be prescribed, or explain how a Commissioner’s application for judicial review relates to the court application for confirmation.
  • The bill sets out no funding source, staffing level, appeal process or reporting requirement for the new Board.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give workplace violence, harassment and discrimination a clearer place in municipal codes of conduct.
  • Mandatory annual training and a duty to report violations could make members’ responsibilities more explicit.
  • A common framework could set shared minimum standards and timelines while requiring protections against reprisals and trauma-informed complaint handling.
  • Court confirmation and possible loss of a seat for egregious failures could provide a serious consequence for severe misconduct.

Case against#

  • The bill assigns broad duties and creates a Board before setting out its procedures, resources or relationship with existing processes.
  • The Minister would decide many important details later, including standards, penalties and timelines. The bill does not set limits on what other matters the framework may cover.
  • A judge could remove an elected or appointed member and bar them from the same council or board through the second subsequent regular election. The bill does not detail the process for assessing whether a failure was “egregious.”
  • The training, Board and framework could require public resources, but the available material gives no cost estimate or funding plan.