Flood-avoidance bill mandates rainwater tanks, online claims histories

Summary#

Bill 179, the Flood Avoidance, Insurance and Recovery Statute Law Amendment Act, 2017, would amend Ontario’s Building Code Act, 1992, Insurance Act and Municipal Affairs Act. Its stated goal is to address flood avoidance, insurance and recovery. The bill says it would start three months after Royal Assent.

  • The building code would require a building for residential occupancy to have a downspout that flows into a rainwater tank with a capacity of at least 204 litres.
  • Insurers would have to publish, on their websites, the property-insurance claims history for each insured residential property in Ontario, as far as the insurer knows.
  • For insurance contracts made in Ontario that cover damage from water, insurers could not refuse to issue, end or refuse to renew a contract because of water damage or related claims if an emergency had been declared for the time and place of the damage. The bill includes exceptions by reference to the Insurance Act.
  • The Minister of Municipal Affairs would have to provide disaster recovery assistance to owners whose residential property suffers sewer-backup flooding linked to a sudden, unexpected natural disaster causing costly and widespread property damage. This duty applies only if the Legislature appropriates money for it, and assistance cannot depend on the owners’ income.

What it means for you#

  • Owners of residential buildings: The building-code rule would require the downspout and tank described above. The bill does not say whether or how the requirement applies to existing buildings.
  • People with residential property insurance: Their property’s claims history would be made public on the insurer’s website. The bill does not specify what identifying details would appear.
  • People affected by water damage during a declared emergency: An insurer could not refuse to issue, end or refuse to renew a contract for the specified water-damage or claims reasons. This does not itself require an insurer to pay a particular claim or provide coverage for every type of water damage.
  • Owners whose homes are flooded by sewer backup: They would qualify for assistance only if the damage meets the bill’s disaster conditions and money has been appropriated. Income would not be a basis for limiting assistance.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s total cost or the amount of any assistance.

  • The recovery-assistance duty depends on the Legislature appropriating money; the bill sets no amount.
  • The bill does not say who would pay for installing or maintaining the required tanks, or how much that would cost.
  • No fees, taxes or fines are set out in the supplied text.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “costly and widespread” or explain how officials would decide whether a disaster meets that test.
  • It does not set assistance amounts, application rules, decision timelines or appeal rights.
  • It does not say how the tank requirement would apply to existing buildings.
  • It does not specify what information insurers must publish beyond the claims history, or how privacy would be protected.
  • The Insurance Act provisions that set out exceptions and related information rules were not supplied, so their effect cannot be verified here. The parent Acts were also not supplied, so current law and how the amendments would interact with it cannot be verified.
  • The supplied material does not establish whether the bill became law.

Case for#

  • A rainwater tank requirement could be seen as a way to encourage some rainwater to be collected at residential buildings, supporting the bill’s flood-avoidance goal.
  • Public claims histories could give people more information about a property’s insurance claims before making decisions about it.
  • Limiting insurers’ ability to act on water damage or related claims after a declared emergency could protect affected property owners from losing access to an insurance contract for those reasons.
  • Assistance without an income test could treat owners affected by a qualifying sewer-backup disaster on the basis of the damage, rather than household income.

Case against#

  • The bill does not explain how the tank requirement would work for existing buildings or who would bear installation costs.
  • Publishing claims histories could expose sensitive property-related information; the bill does not explain what details would be public or how privacy would be protected.
  • The insurance protection is limited to cases where an emergency was declared for the time and place of the damage. The bill does not explain how the rule would work alongside the referenced exceptions.
  • Recovery assistance is limited to sewer-backup flooding tied to a disaster meeting undefined conditions, and depends on an appropriation. The bill does not set an amount or explain how owners would obtain assistance.