Summary#
Bill 203, the Pay Transparency Act, 2018, would create a new Ontario law. Its stated goal is to require disclosure of information about employee and prospective employee compensation. The bill says it would come into force on January 1, 2019, if enacted.
- Employers could not seek a job applicant’s compensation history, with exceptions for information the applicant volunteers without prompting, information already public, and information about comparable positions.
- Employers advertising a specific job to the general public would have to include expected compensation or a range.
- Employers set by regulation would have to prepare and submit pay transparency reports about their workforce and compensation differences by gender and other characteristics, then post the reports for employees. The Ministry could publish them.
- Employers could not penalize employees for specified actions, including asking about or disclosing compensation and raising concerns about compliance.
- The Minister could appoint compliance officers. They could audit employers without a warrant, enter and inspect places, demand and examine records, and question people. They could issue notices of contravention and penalties, with amounts set by regulation.
What it means for you#
- Job applicants: An employer could not ask you for your compensation history, except for the stated exceptions. The bill would not prevent employers from asking about compensation for comparable positions or, in some cases, using information obtained or volunteered under those exceptions.
- Employees: You would have protection from employer retaliation for the actions listed in the bill. A complaint could go to arbitration under a collective agreement, if one applies, or to the Ontario Labour Relations Board. Special rules apply to people subject to a police discipline code.
- Employers: You would have to include compensation information in public job postings. Employers covered by future regulations would also have reporting and posting duties. The bill does not set wages or require employers to offer a particular pay rate.
- Workers and employers subject to an audit: Officers could require records and answers and could enter and inspect places without a warrant. The bill does not create a general application or review process for every employer; it authorizes audits to investigate possible breaches or check compliance.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- Employers could face costs to meet posting and reporting duties, but the bill gives no estimate.
- The bill allows compliance officers to be appointed in numbers considered necessary; it gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- Penalties would be paid to the Minister of Finance, but the amounts or ranges would be set by regulation and are not in the bill text supplied.
What is unclear#
- The bill leaves key details to regulations, including which employers must report, reporting periods, report contents, and which characteristics beyond gender would be covered.
- Regulations could also exempt classes of employers and set penalty amounts or ranges. Those details are not provided.
- The rules for conducting audits, including related inspections and investigations, would also be set by regulation.
- The bill does not say how the Ministry would use reports it publishes, or how much information reports would reveal about particular employees.
- The bill text sets a start date, but enactment and the required regulations are not established by the supplied material.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make compensation practices more visible and to address differences in pay across a workforce.
- A possible argument for banning employers from asking about salary history is that an applicant’s previous pay would not be the starting point for setting pay in a new job.
- Requiring expected pay or a range in public job postings could give applicants useful information before they apply.
- Protecting employees who discuss pay or raise compliance concerns could make it easier for them to share information about pay practices.
Case against#
- Employers would face new posting and, for some, reporting duties, but the bill gives no cost estimates or limits on which employers would be covered.
- The bill gives officers broad audit powers, including entry without a warrant and demands for records and answers. The supplied text does not include the regulations that would govern how audits are carried out.
- Reporting could reveal sensitive workforce information. The bill allows the Ministry to publish reports but does not set out the publication details in the supplied text.
- The bill leaves penalty amounts and important reporting rules to later regulations, so the practical reach and cost of the requirements are not clear from the bill alone.