Bill would curb secrecy in harassment NDAs

Summary#

Bill 124, the Stopping the Misuse of Non-Disclosure Agreements Act, 2023, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend another Act. Its stated goal is to regulate non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) about discrimination, harassment, sexual harassment and sexual assault.

  • It would generally prohibit a person with a legal duty to take reasonable steps to prevent such conduct, or the person who committed or is alleged to have committed it, from making an NDA with someone who experienced or alleged it if the agreement conceals details of the complaint.
  • An agreement could still be made if it is the relevant person’s expressed wish and preference. To be enforceable, it must meet conditions including a reasonable opportunity for independent legal advice, no undue attempts to influence the person, no adverse effect on a third party’s health or safety or the public interest, a future way to waive confidentiality, and a set, limited duration.
  • The bill lists communications and disclosures that the agreement cannot restrict, including disclosures protected or required by law; communications with specified professionals, enforcement officials, supporters and others; and certain artistic expression. It also protects certain communications with prospective employers.
  • It would treat non-disparagement agreements that conceal details in the same way as NDAs. Confidentiality about the amount paid in a settlement would still be allowed.
  • A non-compliant agreement would have no legal effect. Entering one could also be an offence, punishable on summary conviction by a $10,000 fine for an individual, or a fine of $10,000 to $50,000 for a corporation.
  • A party responsible could not make a separate NDA with the person who committed or is alleged to have committed the conduct to prevent a lawful investigation into a harassment or discrimination complaint.

What it means for you#

  • People who experienced or alleged the conduct: A responsible party or alleged perpetrator generally could not use an NDA to conceal the complaint’s details. The person could choose to enter one, but it would need to meet the bill’s enforceability conditions. The agreement could not block the listed disclosures, including speaking with a friend, family member, lawyer, health professional or victim-services provider.
  • Employers and other responsible parties: If you have a legal duty to take reasonable steps to prevent the conduct in a place where it occurred or was alleged, the bill would restrict NDAs you make with a relevant person. It would also prohibit an NDA with the alleged perpetrator intended to prevent a lawful investigation.
  • People accused of the conduct: The same general restriction on NDAs with a relevant person would apply to you. A non-compliant agreement could have no legal effect and could lead to a fine.
  • People with existing agreements: The bill says existing NDAs would be subject to certain disclosure exceptions. It is unclear whether or how the main ban would affect agreements made before the Act starts.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill sets fines for offences, but does not estimate how much would be collected.
  • It does not state what staffing, enforcement or compliance would cost, or whether additional resources would be provided.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define key terms such as “expressed wish and preference,” “undue attempts to influence,” or “set and limited duration.” It allows regulations to define terms and add rules.
  • It does not set out a process for reporting suspected violations, deciding whether an agreement meets the conditions, or reviewing a decision.
  • It does not name who would investigate or prosecute the offences.
  • It does not clearly explain how the main ban applies to existing agreements, beyond making specified disclosure exceptions apply to them.
  • The bill does not give a start date beyond saying it would come into force on Royal Assent. The supplied material does not establish the bill’s current status.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to stop agreements from hiding details of discrimination, harassment, sexual harassment or sexual assault when a relevant person does not want that secrecy.
  • Allowing an agreement when the relevant person expressly wants one recognizes that the person may prefer confidentiality.
  • The conditions and disclosure exceptions aim to preserve access to advice, support, legally required disclosure and certain future employment communications.
  • The bill would also prevent an NDA from being used to block a lawful investigation into a harassment or discrimination complaint.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves important standards undefined, including what counts as undue influence and a limited duration. That could make it hard to know in advance whether an agreement is enforceable.
  • It does not set out a complaint, investigation or review process for alleged violations, or identify who would enforce the offence provisions.
  • The exception depends on the relevant person’s expressed wish, but the bill does not specify how that wish must be recorded or confirmed.
  • The treatment of existing agreements is not fully clear, which could leave uncertainty for people and organizations with agreements already in place.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2023030603

    Defeated97 members voted

    Marit Stiles moved, Whereas there is a mental health crisis in Ontario; and Whereas demand for services provided by the Canadian Mental Health Association has significantly increased, including demand for…

    AGAINST · 65FOR · 32

    65Against

    • PC65

    32For

    • NDP24
    • Liberal7
    • Green1
  2. Division No. 2023022701

    Defeated99 members voted

    Marit Stiles moved, Whereas more than a third of operating rooms in Ontario's public hospitals do not meet the 90 per cent target for operating room use, mostly due to…

    AGAINST · 66FOR · 33

    66Against

    • PC66

    33For

    • NDP27
    • Liberal5
    • Green1
  3. Division No. 2022111601

    Defeated102 members voted

    France Gélinas moved, Whereas staffing shortages in Ontario have forced emergency room and ICU closures across Ontario, reducing access to complex and potentially life-saving care in many communities; and Whereas…

    AGAINST · 74FOR · 28

    74Against

    • PC74

    28For

    • NDP21
    • Liberal6
    • Green1