Summary#
Bill 28, the All Families Are Equal Act (Parentage and Related Registrations Statute Law Amendment), 2016, was enacted as Chapter 23 of Ontario’s 2016 statutes. It amends the Children’s Law Reform Act, the Vital Statistics Act, the Succession Law Reform Act and many other Acts; it does not create a new standalone agency or program. Its stated goal is to set parentage rules that apply for all purposes of Ontario law.
- The Children’s Law Reform Act sets out who is a child’s legal parent, including rules for assisted reproduction, donor conception, surrogacy, parentage agreements and court declarations.
- A written agreement made before conception can establish parentage for up to four parties, subject to conditions. Surrogacy rules require independent legal advice and the surrogate’s written consent after the child is at least seven days old; agreements with more than four intended parents require a court application.
- Courts may declare parentage, including parentage involving more than two parents, only under stated conditions. Ontario courts must recognize many parentage orders from outside Ontario, subject to exceptions.
- The Vital Statistics Act is changed to reflect these rules in birth registrations and to set surname rules for children with more than two parents. The Registrar General must amend a registration after receiving a certified court order.
- The Succession Law Reform Act allows some children conceived after a parent’s death to count for inheritance and support claims, if notice, timing and court-declaration conditions are met.
What it means for you#
- Children and parents: A child’s legal parents are determined under the new rules, not solely by who provided sperm, an egg or an embryo. For assisted reproduction, a birth parent’s spouse may also be a parent unless the spouse did not consent or withdrew consent before conception.
- People making parentage agreements: A pre-conception agreement must be in writing and meet the Act’s conditions. It does not make every person named a parent automatically; the rules depend on how the child is conceived and who is a party.
- Surrogates and intended parents: For agreements with up to four intended parents, the surrogate’s consent to relinquish parentage cannot be given before the child is seven days old. The agreement itself is not enforceable in law. If there are more than four intended parents, a court must decide parentage.
- People seeking a court declaration: A court may declare that a child has more than two parents only if the other parents are parties, there was shared intent before conception, and the declaration is in the child’s best interests, among other conditions.
- Children conceived after a parent’s death: The surviving spouse must give written notice within six months. The child must be born within three years of the death unless a court extends the time, and a court must declare the deceased person a parent.
- Birth registration and family records: The Act changes who may certify a birth and how surnames are chosen for children with more than two parents. It also updates many laws to use the new parentage rules. It does not create a general new front-line service.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The Act assigns duties to the Registrar General and allows parentage applications to courts, but the material gives no staffing, administrative or court-cost estimate.
- Some applications and certified copies may require a fee where the Vital Statistics Act requires one. The material does not give fee amounts or say that this Act creates a new fee.
What is unclear#
- Some provisions start on Royal Assent; others depend on proclamation or dates tied to other Acts. The material does not give the proclamation dates or confirm which provisions have started. No publicly available information.
- The Act leaves some birth-registration details to regulations, including what information and documents must be provided.
- The supplied material does not include the full parent Acts or later amendments, so I could not verify every change against current law.
- The material does not explain how the new rules interact with every existing program or process that uses parentage.
Case for#
- The Act appears intended to make legal parentage rules fit different ways families may have children, including assisted reproduction and surrogacy.
- A possible argument for the rules is that they can recognize intended parents while requiring the surrogate’s post-birth consent before parentage changes under the standard surrogacy process.
- The rules also give courts a way to consider more complex cases, including arrangements involving more than four intended parents.
- Recognizing some posthumously conceived children for inheritance and support purposes could give them legal standing, if the stated safeguards are met.
Case against#
- One concern is that important details depend on regulations or court decisions, so people may not know how a rule applies until those details are set or a case is decided.
- The surrogacy agreement is unenforceable, and parentage can depend on consent given after birth. That may leave uncertainty if the surrogate and intended parents disagree.
- Court applications can add steps for families, especially where an agreement involves more than four intended parents or a required consent is not given.
- The posthumous-conception rules may affect estate planning and administration, but the material gives no estimate of the costs or practical effects.