Summary#
Bill 87, Vital Statistics Amendment Act, 2023, would amend Ontario’s Vital Statistics Act. Its stated goal is to provide greater access to information related to adoptions. It would extend some access and contact rules to specified relatives of deceased adopted people and birth parents, and allow information-sharing agreements with authorities in other provinces and territories.
- It defines “next of kin” for these rules: for an adopted person, the person’s descendants; for a birth parent, the birth parent’s descendants, parent or sibling.
- A next of kin of a deceased adopted person could apply for certain uncertified copies of records. A next of kin of a deceased birth parent could apply for certain adoption information, subject to age limits and other rules.
- It extends contact preferences and disclosure veto rules to cover these relatives. A person who receives notice that contact is not wanted must not knowingly contact, or try to contact, the other person; contacting through someone else is also prohibited.
- The Registrar General may make agreements with authorities in other provinces or territories to share information for specified purposes. The Registrar General may disclose information only if an Ontario or other Act authorizes it.
- The bill would make breaches of the contact rules offences, with maximum fines of $50,000 for an individual and $250,000 for a corporation.
What it means for you#
- Next of kin of a deceased adopted person: If you are at least 18, you could apply for the specified records. You would have to pay any required fee and provide identity, age and death evidence that the Registrar General requires.
- Next of kin of a deceased birth parent: You could apply for the specified adoption information if you are at least 18 and the adopted person is at least 19. Fees and evidence requirements would apply.
- Adopted people and birth parents: The bill would extend existing notice and veto rules to include the relevant relatives of a deceased person. It does not make every relative eligible: the bill’s definition of next of kin is limited to the listed family relationships.
- People who receive a no-contact notice: You must not knowingly contact or try to contact the person who does not want contact, directly or indirectly. The bill also bars someone else from contacting that person on your behalf.
- The Registrar General: The office may enter into cross-border information-sharing agreements, but the bill does not require it to make any agreement.
- People generally: The bill does not directly change taxes, benefits or adoption eligibility.
Money#
No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.
- Applicants would pay any required fee for the records or information; the bill does not state the fee amount.
- The bill does not set out a budget or staffing amount for the Registrar General. It may create administrative work, but the cost is not stated.
- The bill sets maximum fines of $50,000 for an individual and $250,000 for a corporation for offences under the contact rules.
What is unclear#
- The current Vital Statistics Act was not supplied, so the existing access, notice, veto and contact rules—and the full extent of the changes—could not be checked against current law.
- The bill does not set out how applications would be made, how long decisions would take, or how an applicant could challenge a decision.
- It leaves the Registrar General to decide what evidence of identity, age and death may be required, and does not state any required fee.
- The bill does not specify what information-sharing agreements must contain, or how privacy and security would be handled beyond requiring legal authority to disclose information.
- The bill would start on Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not establish whether it has received Royal Assent.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to let certain relatives seek adoption information when the adopted person or birth parent has died.
- Extending the rules to next of kin could allow some family members to seek records or information they could not apply for in their own right under the provisions as described in the bill.
- Agreements with other provinces and territories could help authorities check whether a disclosure veto or contact preference has been filed there or in Ontario.
- The bill keeps limits: it defines which relatives qualify, sets age thresholds, and allows disclosure only when authorized by law.
Case against#
- Adoption records can contain sensitive information. Extending access to relatives may expose information that the people named in the records would not have chosen to share.
- The bill does not explain how applications would be handled, what evidence is enough, or how applicants could appeal. Those details may affect how predictable access is.
- The Registrar General may make information-sharing agreements, but the bill does not spell out their privacy safeguards or require public reporting on them.
- The contact rules carry substantial maximum fines, while the supplied text does not explain how disputes about a notice or contact would be handled.