Bill adds genetic protections against discrimination

Summary#

Bill 30, Human Rights Code Amendment Act (Genetic Characteristics), 2016, would amend Ontario’s Human Rights Code; it would not create a separate law or agency. Its stated goal is to add genetic characteristics as a ground protected from discrimination. If enacted, it would take effect on Royal Assent.

  • The bill adds genetic characteristics to Code provisions on equal treatment in services, accommodation, contracts, employment and membership in organizations.
  • It defines genetic characteristics to include traits that may cause or raise the risk of a disorder or disease.
  • It expressly protects a person from discrimination for refusing a genetic test, refusing to share test results, or refusing to authorize their release.
  • It creates an exception for certain insurance and annuity contracts: when benefits exceed $1 million in total or $75,000 per year, the contract may distinguish on reasonable and bona fide grounds because of genetic characteristics.
  • It also adds genetic characteristics to an existing exception in the Code. The supplied material does not include that exception’s wording, so its scope cannot be confirmed.

What it means for you#

  • Workers and job applicants: The bill would add genetic characteristics to the grounds for equal treatment in employment. It would also protect refusal to take or disclose a genetic test. The bill does not require anyone to take a test or disclose results.
  • People using services, renting accommodation or making contracts: The bill would add genetic characteristics as a protected ground in these areas.
  • People seeking insurance or an annuity: The bill would not ban insurers from making every distinction based on genetic characteristics. For the listed contracts, it provides an exception when the benefit threshold is exceeded and the distinction is on reasonable and bona fide grounds.
  • People seeking membership in organizations: The bill would add genetic characteristics to the Code provisions covering membership in various types of organizations.
  • The bill does not set out a new complaint process, decision timeline or appeal process.

Money#

No cost estimate is given in the supplied material.

  • The bill does not state a public appropriation, fee or fine.
  • No publicly available information is provided about implementation or enforcement costs.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current Human Rights Code. I could not verify the Code’s exact current wording, existing exceptions or how this bill would interact with them.
  • The bill does not define “genetic test” or explain how “reasonable and bona fide grounds” would be assessed.
  • The bill does not explain how the insurance benefit thresholds would be applied in practice.
  • The scope of the added wording in the existing exception under section 24(1)(a) cannot be assessed without that section’s text.
  • The bill does not specify how affected people would make or resolve a claim.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that genetic traits, including disease risks, should not be a reason for unequal treatment in the areas covered by the Code.
  • Protecting people who refuse testing or disclosure could help make that protection meaningful, rather than leaving people to choose between privacy and equal treatment.
  • The insurance exception is limited to contracts above stated benefit thresholds and requires reasonable and bona fide grounds.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the insurance exception would still allow some distinctions based on genetic characteristics in higher-benefit contracts. The bill does not explain how the required grounds would be tested.
  • The added exception in section 24(1)(a) could limit the new protection, but its effect is unclear from the supplied material.
  • The bill does not set out claim procedures or explain how the new protection would work alongside existing Code exceptions.