Right to Care for Teens 16-17

Summary#

Bill 32, the Right to Care Act (Children 16 Years of Age and Older), 2016, would amend Ontario’s Child and Family Services Act. Its stated goal is to recognize that services under that Act should follow the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child. The supplied material says the law then barred temporary care agreements for people aged 16 and older; I could not verify that against the Act itself.

  • A 16- or 17-year-old could ask their local children’s aid society for a written temporary care agreement if the person with custody is temporarily unable to care for them adequately.
  • If the society determines that this condition is met, it must not refuse to make the agreement. The bill does not set out a separate application or review process.
  • A child aged 12 or older must be a party to a temporary care agreement.
  • An agreement could last up to six months at first. With a Director’s written approval, it could be extended, up to a total of 24 months for a child aged 16 or 17 when the agreement is made.
  • The bill would make three existing conditions in the Act inapplicable to agreements for 16- and 17-year-olds. The supplied material does not say what those conditions are.
  • The bill says temporary agreements do not prevent care and maintenance under section 71.1 or the regulations, or eligible Ontario Works or disability-support assistance.

What it means for you#

  • Young people aged 16 or 17: You could ask for a temporary care agreement if the person with custody is temporarily unable to care for you adequately. The society must not refuse if it makes that determination. The bill does not create an unconditional right to an agreement in every situation.
  • Children’s aid societies: They would have to consider a request under the stated condition and could not refuse if they determine that condition is met.
  • People with custody: The bill refers to the person who has custody, not only a parent. It does not otherwise change that person’s duties or set out how inability to provide care would be assessed.
  • People receiving support: The bill says these agreements do not, by themselves, bar specified care or income support. It does not change the eligibility rules for those supports.
  • General public: The bill would add a purpose statement about the UN Convention. It does not set out a new service program or create a separate organization.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not provide a spending estimate or say how many staff or other resources societies would need.
  • It does not state a fee, fine, tax, or payment to young people.

What is unclear#

  • The parent Act was not supplied, so I could not verify the bill’s description of current law or identify the three conditions it would remove for 16- and 17-year-olds.
  • The bill does not define “temporarily unable to care adequately” or explain how a society must decide whether that condition is met.
  • It does not set out timelines, written reasons, review or appeal rights, or reporting requirements for requests.
  • It does not explain how agreements would work with other care arrangements or supports beyond saying they are not barred.
  • The bill would start six months after Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not establish whether it became law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to let 16- and 17-year-olds seek temporary care when the person with custody cannot adequately care for them.
  • Requiring the child to be a party to an agreement at age 12 or older gives the child a formal role in it.
  • Allowing extensions for up to 24 months could provide more time than a short initial agreement when temporary care is still needed.
  • The purpose statement would direct attention to the UN Convention when services under the Act are provided.

Case against#

  • A young person’s access depends on the society determining that the custodial person is temporarily unable to care adequately; the bill does not explain how that decision is made.
  • The bill gives no process for challenging a refusal or disagreement about whether the condition is met.
  • The bill removes three conditions for older children without the supplied material explaining what protections or limits those conditions provide.
  • The bill requires society staff and a Director’s written approval for extensions, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.