Caregivers gain rights in care settings

Summary#

Bill 19 would create a new Ontario law, the More Than a Visitor Act (Caregiving in Congregate Care Settings), 2021. It would require the Minister to protect specified rights for people receiving care, support or services in listed settings and for their designated caregivers; its stated goal is to recognize caregivers as partners in care.

  • The settings covered include long-term care and retirement homes; public and private hospitals; independent health facilities; hospices and palliative-care facilities; supportive housing; intervenor residential sites; developmental-disability group homes; children’s residences and custody or detention places; certain violence-against-women and anti-human-trafficking residential services; and emergency homeless shelters. Some home and community care settings would be covered only on a day set by the Minister.
  • A designated caregiver must provide significant, unpaid, non-professional support, share an emotional bond with the person, and be chosen by that person or their substitute decision-maker. More than one caregiver may be designated, and the designation may be revoked.
  • The Minister would have to ensure access to designated caregivers, including safe reintegration of caregivers excluded because of the COVID-19 pandemic. Infection-control protocols would have to provide a way to safely integrate caregivers during a crisis or emergency.
  • The Minister would have to provide operators with support, resources and training, and ensure they have resources to implement the Act’s rights and strategy.
  • The Minister would have to create an interim strategy within one month of Royal Assent, then a caregiving strategy within one year. The strategy must include a staffing strategy for each type of covered setting so caregivers supplement, rather than replace, care or support.
  • The Act would not change workers’ roles or collective-bargaining rights, or override laws on substitute decisions, personal health information or health-care consent.

What it means for you#

  • People receiving care and designated caregivers: The Minister must ensure five rights are respected and promoted: access to the caregiver according to the person’s needs and preferences; not treating the caregiver merely as a visitor; the person’s choice about caregiver involvement in, and information about, decisions; confidential communication in the person’s preferred manner; and dignity and respect for both. These rights remain in effect during a crisis or emergency.
  • Care-setting operators: They would have to receive and use resources intended to implement the rights and strategy. The bill does not set out specific operator procedures.
  • Workers: The bill says it does not change workers’ roles and responsibilities or affect collective-bargaining rights. It says caregivers supplement formal paid care, not replace it.
  • Government: The Minister would have to consult people receiving care, caregivers and their representative groups, service providers, staff and their representative groups, and researchers and experts. The Minister must publish the strategy and updates on a government website.
  • People in covered settings: The bill creates rights and duties, but does not set up an application or complaint process, timelines for decisions, or appeals.

Money#

The bill requires the Minister to ensure operators have resources, but the available material gives no cost estimate.

  • No amount is specified for operator resources, training, staffing strategies or the Minister’s work.
  • The bill does not set fees, fines, taxes or benefits.

What is unclear#

  • “Significant” support and “emotional bond” are not defined.
  • The bill does not explain how access rights would work alongside infection-control measures, or how conflicts between a person’s preferences and other legal requirements would be handled.
  • It does not set out how rights would be enforced, how complaints would be handled, or what remedy a person could seek.
  • The Minister must include a strategy to prevent the Government from unilaterally developing policies about caregivers’ roles, but the bill does not explain how that limit would work in practice.
  • The Minister sets the day when the specified home and community care settings become covered; the bill gives no date.
  • The amount and source of resources for operators, and how much staffing the strategies would require, are not stated.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to protect relationships that may be important to a person’s care and well-being, including during emergencies.
  • Treating designated caregivers differently from visitors could help recognize that they provide ongoing, unpaid support.
  • The bill requires the Minister to provide operator support and resources, while stating that caregivers supplement paid care rather than replace it.
  • Required consultation and public posting of the strategy could bring different experiences into the planning process and make the strategy available to the public.

Case against#

  • The bill creates broad rights but does not provide a complaint, enforcement or appeal process, leaving unclear how a person could address a breach.
  • Terms such as “significant” support are undefined, and the bill does not spell out how the rights would be applied in specific settings or emergencies.
  • The resource and staffing duties could require public spending, but the bill provides no cost estimate or funding plan.
  • The strategy must address many different kinds of settings, but the bill does not explain how one strategy would account for their different needs.