Expands protections for children and youth

Summary#

Bill 89, Supporting Children, Youth and Families Act, 2017, received Royal Assent and became Chapter 14 of Ontario’s 2017 statutes. It repeals the Child and Family Services Act, replaces it with the Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017, and makes related changes to 36 other Acts. Its stated goal is to promote children’s best interests, protection and well-being; it also aims to recognize children’s rights, family strengths and cultural connections. The new Act’s start date is set by proclamation, and the supplied material does not give the dates when its provisions took effect.

  • The new Act extends child protection to 16- and 17-year-olds, but they cannot be brought to a place of safety without their consent. Anyone may report concerns about them, but the mandatory duty to report applies only to children under 16.
  • It sets out rights for children and young people receiving services, including rights to express their views, take part in decisions and raise concerns. It restricts physical and mechanical restraints, with exceptions set by the Act and regulations.
  • It adds duties and powers for children’s aid societies and the Minister. Societies must investigate protection concerns and protect children up to age 18, and must have an accountability agreement to receive funding. The Minister may order societies to amalgamate or restructure and may appoint a supervisor to run a society.
  • It requires efforts toward customary care for some First Nations, Inuit and Métis children, and gives those children’s bands and communities notice and participation rights in specified matters. A society may provide a subsidy for customary care.
  • It creates detailed rules for service providers’ collection, use and sharing of personal information, and gives individuals rights to access and seek correction of their records.

What it means for you#

  • Children and young people: If you receive services under the Act, you have rights to be heard, be told about your rights and complain about alleged rights violations. For a child in residential care, a plan of care must be prepared within 30 days of admission.
  • Young people aged 16 or 17: A society may make a voluntary agreement for services and supports if the young person wants one and the society finds less disruptive options cannot adequately protect them. The agreement can last up to 24 months in total and cannot continue past age 18.
  • Parents and families: The law changes the factors used in child-protection and adoption decisions. These include the child’s views, and, for First Nations, Inuit and Métis children, the importance of cultural identity and community connection.
  • First Nations, Inuit and Métis communities: Societies and other service providers must regularly consult with bands and communities about services and matters affecting children. Some specific services or powers also require consultation under rules set by regulation.
  • Children’s aid societies and service providers: They must follow the Act, regulations and applicable Ministerial directives. Residential-care licensees must charge amounts set by regulation unless exempted.
  • People whose personal information is held by service providers: You generally have rights to access your personal information and ask for corrections, subject to exceptions in the Act. The Act also permits some collection, use and sharing without consent.
  • Taxpayers: The Act allows public funding for services, lead agencies and some customary-care subsidies. It does not set out a total cost.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The Act requires funding for children’s aid societies from money appropriated by the Legislature; regulations determine the amounts. Funding is conditional on an accountability agreement.
  • The Minister may fund services and lead agencies, and societies or entities may grant customary-care subsidies. The material gives no total or per-program estimate.
  • The Act authorizes paid appointments and permits payments to some committees, but gives no staffing or cost estimates.

What is unclear#

  • The exact dates when the new Act and its amendments took effect are not in the supplied material.
  • Many practical rules—including services for 16- and 17-year-olds, restraint standards, lead-agency functions and funding amounts—are left to regulations.
  • The Act gives the Minister broad power to order society restructuring, but the material does not say how often that power would be used or what changes would be made.
  • First Nations, Inuit and Métis communities are included on lists made by regulation with their representatives’ consent. The supplied material does not say which communities were listed or how consultation works in practice.
  • The supplied material does not estimate the cost of the new duties, privacy rules, oversight or possible restructuring.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to extend child-protection services to 16- and 17-year-olds while requiring their consent before they are brought to a place of safety.
  • A possible argument for the new rights and privacy rules is that children and families should be heard and treated with respect, while personal information is handled under clear limits.
  • The Act’s consultation, placement and customary-care provisions could be seen as ways to protect First Nations, Inuit and Métis children’s ties to their communities and cultures.
  • Ministerial oversight and restructuring powers could help address society failures or improve the consistency of services; the Act identifies service quality and operational management as matters the Minister may consider.

Case against#

  • The Act gives the Minister significant power over societies, including power to appoint board members or a supervisor and to order amalgamation or other restructuring. Societies may respond to proposed restructuring directions, but not to the requirement to amalgamate itself.
  • The Act says no compensation is payable for losses arising from certain Ministerial or supervisor actions, including transfers of property under restructuring orders.
  • Important details depend on regulations, including funding amounts and standards for several services. Without those details, the practical effects and costs are hard to judge.
  • The Act permits some personal-information collection, use and sharing without consent. Although it adds limits and oversight, its application depends on rules and exceptions that may affect how much information is shared.

Votes

4 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2017060102

    Passed86 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 89

    FOR · 63AGAINST · 23

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    63For

    • Liberal52
    • NDP11

    23Against

    • PC22
    • Independent1
  2. Division No. 2017053001

    Passed92 members voted

    Government Notice of Motion Number 33 for allocation of time on Bill 89, An Act to enact the Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017, to amend and repeal the…

    FOR · 52AGAINST · 40

    52For

    • Liberal52

    40Against

    • PC22
    • NDP17
    • Independent1
  3. Division No. 2017030902

    Passed83 members voted

    Motion for closure on Second Reading of Bill 89

    FOR · 50AGAINST · 33

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    50For

    • Liberal50

    33Against

    • PC18
    • NDP15
  4. Division No. 2017030903

    Passed83 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 89

    FOR · 83

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    83For

    • Liberal50
    • PC18
    • NDP15

    0Against