Public Safety Bill Ends Pit Bull Rules

Summary#

Bill 40, the Public Safety Related to Dogs Statute Law Amendment Act, 2016, would amend the Animals for Research Act and the Dog Owners’ Liability Act; it would not create a new law or agency. Its stated goal, as indicated by its title, is public safety related to dogs.

  • It would remove pit bull-related provisions about the disposition of dogs under the Animals for Research Act.
  • It would remove the “pit bull” definition and provisions that prohibit restricted pit bulls and control pit bulls under the Dog Owners’ Liability Act, including revoking Ontario Regulation 157/05.
  • It would require courts, when making certain orders, to consider circumstances listed in the Act. The bill text supplied does not include that list.
  • It would let the government make regulations authorizing specified people or bodies to pass and enforce dog by-laws in unorganized territory, and to designate bodies and public officers as peace officers for this Act. These are powers, not automatic authorizations.
  • Most changes to the Dog Owners’ Liability Act would start on a day set by proclamation. The Animals for Research Act changes would start on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Dog owners: If enacted, the bill would remove the breed-specific prohibitions and controls described in the explanatory note. The supplied materials do not show how this would affect existing orders or other dog rules.
  • People in unorganized territory: Regulations could authorize specified bodies or people to make and enforce dog by-laws there. The bill does not itself name those bodies or put a by-law system in place.
  • Public officers and designated bodies: Regulations could designate public officers as peace officers and designate bodies for purposes of the Act.
  • People affected by animal research rules: The bill would remove pit bull-related disposition provisions, but the supplied text does not explain the practical effect of those provisions under current law.
  • General public: The bill does not create a new front-line service. Its passage status is not provided, so these changes are not yet established by the supplied material as law.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s costs is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill text gives no cost estimate, appropriation, fee, or staffing amount.
  • It allows regulations that could authorize bodies to enforce dog by-laws, but does not say whether this would require new spending or staff.

What is unclear#

  • The current versions of the two Acts and the regulation are not supplied, so I could not verify the full current rules or the exact effect of each repeal.
  • The bill changes the wording for what courts must consider, but the full list of circumstances is not included in the supplied text.
  • It also removes specified clauses in sections 13 and 15 of the Dog Owners’ Liability Act. Without the parent Act, their effect cannot be verified.
  • The bill does not say which bodies or officers would be designated, or what dog by-laws they would make or enforce.
  • The bill does not explain how its changes would interact with existing orders or other dog rules.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would remove separate breed-specific restrictions and controls, rather than keep rules focused on pit bulls.
  • Courts would still be required to consider circumstances listed in the Act when making certain orders.
  • Regulations could allow dog by-laws in unorganized territory, where the bill says authorized bodies could have powers like those of municipalities.

Case against#

  • One concern is that removing breed-specific prohibitions and controls could reduce a specific tool for addressing risks linked to restricted pit bulls; the materials do not explain what would replace it.
  • The bill does not provide the full circumstances courts must consider, making it hard to assess how court orders would work after the changes.
  • The regulation-making powers leave important details—such as which bodies would enforce by-laws—to later decisions.
  • The cost and staffing implications are not estimated.