Summary#
Bill 147, the Public Safety Related to Dogs Statute Law Amendment Act, 2019, would amend Ontario’s Animals for Research Act and Dog Owners’ Liability Act. Its stated goal is public safety; that goal is not a guaranteed result. The bill says it would take effect on Royal Assent.
- It would repeal the Dog Owners’ Liability Act definition of “pit bull,” the pit-bull prohibition and controls described in the bill, and Ontario Regulation 157/05, Pit Bull Controls.
- It would repeal provisions of the Animals for Research Act about disposing of pit bulls under that Act.
- If a court finds, in a proceeding under the Dog Owners’ Liability Act, that a dog made an unprovoked attack that caused a defined severe physical injury or killed someone, the court must declare the dog vicious. It may order the dog destroyed.
- After that declaration, the court must prohibit the owner from owning another dog for at least 10 years. The bill sets a maximum penalty of a $60,000 fine, two years in prison, or both, for an owner who contravenes an order it describes as required under the vicious-dog provision.
- The bill would let the Lieutenant Governor in Council make regulations authorizing specified people or bodies to pass and enforce dog by-laws in unorganized territory, and to designate bodies and public officers for purposes of the Act. This is a regulation-making power, not an immediate creation of by-laws or a new agency.
What it means for you#
- Owners of pit bulls: The bill would remove the provincial breed-based prohibition and controls described above. It does not say that municipal by-laws are repealed; how the change would interact with local rules is unclear.
- Owners of any dog involved in a serious attack: The new court rules would apply to any dog, not only a particular breed. “Severe physical injury” means an injury causing muscle tears or disfiguring lacerations, or requiring multiple sutures or corrective or cosmetic surgery.
- Dog owners facing a vicious-dog finding: The court must ban the owner from owning another dog for at least 10 years from the declaration, and may order the dog destroyed. The bill says an attack is not unprovoked if, at the time, the person was wilfully trespassing or committing another wilful tort on premises occupied by the owner’s dog; committing or attempting a Criminal Code offence; teasing, tormenting, abusing or assaulting the dog; or the dog was defending someone nearby from an unjustified attack or assault.
- People and bodies involved in animal research: The bill would remove the pit-bull disposition rules in the Animals for Research Act. The supplied text does not explain what other rules would apply.
- General public: The bill does not create a new dog-licensing or reporting process.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill includes no spending amount or cost estimate.
- It gives no estimate for court, enforcement, staffing or by-law costs.
What is unclear#
- The parent Acts were not supplied, so the bill’s changes could not be checked against the full current law or other existing rules.
- The bill does not explain how its repeal of provincial pit-bull controls would interact with existing municipal by-laws.
- It does not set out procedures, timelines or appeals for the court process beyond referring to proceedings under the existing Act.
- Terms including “unjustified attack” and “immediate vicinity” are not defined in the supplied text.
- The bill does not explain who would enforce the new owner prohibition, or the expected cost of enforcement.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to shift from breed-based restrictions toward a court response based on a dog’s conduct and the severity of harm.
- A mandatory, minimum 10-year ban on owning another dog may be seen as a way to address serious attacks, while allowing the court to consider whether the attack was unprovoked.
- The bill defines severe physical injury and lists situations in which an attack is not considered unprovoked.
Case against#
- Repealing the provincial breed-specific controls could reduce one layer of restriction; the bill does not explain how local rules would fill any gap.
- The 10-year minimum applies to owning any dog, and the court may also order the dog destroyed. These are serious consequences, while some key terms used in the exceptions are undefined.
- The bill does not provide details about how the court process or enforcement would work, or what they would cost.