Summary#
Bill 80, the Ontario Service Dogs Act, 2016, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend another Act. Its stated goal is to protect the rights of people with disabilities who use service dogs. The supplied text is a bill, not evidence that it became law; it would start on a day set by proclamation.
- It would prohibit denying or discriminating in access to schools and places open to the public because a person with a disability is accompanied by a service dog, or needs a support person or assistive device to help with the dog.
- It would prohibit denying someone occupancy of a self-contained dwelling unit, or discriminating in its terms or conditions, for the same reasons when the person keeps or is customarily accompanied by a service dog.
- These protections would apply despite conflicting Acts, regulations, bylaws or rules, and the Act would bind the Crown.
- The Lieutenant Governor in Council could set service-dog qualifications by regulation. The Attorney General or a written designate could issue identification cards on application; a card would be proof of qualification unless there is evidence to the contrary.
- The bill would make false claims about disability, a service dog, a support person or an assistive device offences. The maximum fine would be $5,000 for violating the access or housing prohibitions and $500 for false representation.
What it means for you#
- People with disabilities using service dogs: If the bill became law, schools, places customarily open to the public, and providers of self-contained dwelling units could not deny access or discriminate for the reasons listed. The bill does not require other services or accommodations for the dog beyond allowing the dog, support person or assistive device as described.
- People providing those places or housing: You would have to follow the prohibitions. A person who contravenes them could face a fine of up to $5,000.
- People applying for identification cards: The Attorney General or a designated ministry officer could issue a card, but the bill does not require one to be issued to every applicant.
- Anyone making a false representation to claim the bill’s protections: You could face a fine of up to $500.
- The public: The bill would not itself require people to apply for cards or create a process for reviewing every service dog or accommodation request.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s estimated cost is included in the supplied material.
- The bill would allow the Attorney General or a designate to issue cards, and would allow regulations setting dog qualifications. It gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- It sets maximum fines, but does not estimate how many fines might be imposed or the revenue they might produce.
What is unclear#
- The bill defines a service dog as a dog trained, or being trained, as a guide for a person with a disability, with qualifications to be set by regulation. The supplied material does not include those regulations.
- The bill does not explain how someone would request an accommodation, how decisions would be made, or what review or appeal process would apply.
- The definition of disability is borrowed from the Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act, 2005; that Act was not supplied, so its wording could not be checked here.
- The bill does not explain how its protections would interact with existing laws or programs beyond saying it applies despite other Acts, regulations, bylaws and rules.
- The supplied material does not establish whether this bill became law or whether regulations were later made.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to prevent people with disabilities from being denied access to public places, schools or housing because they use a qualifying service dog.
- A possible argument for the bill is that clear prohibitions and fines could make these protections more direct.
- Allowing identification cards could give a person a way to show that they and their dog qualify, while the bill does not make cards compulsory.
Case against#
- The bill’s definition focuses on dogs trained as guides; until regulations set qualifications, it is unclear which dogs would qualify.
- The bill gives the Attorney General or a designate power to issue cards but does not set application rules, timelines or a review process.
- The bill says it overrides other laws and rules but does not explain how conflicts would be handled in practice.
- A possible trade-off is that the bill sets fines and broad prohibitions without describing how complaints would be handled or how the rules would be enforced.