Election Finance Reforms Expand Campaign Rules

Summary#

Bill 254, the Protecting Ontario Elections Act, 2021, amends Ontario’s Election Act, Election Finances Act, Members’ Integrity Act, 1994 and Municipal Elections Act, 1996. It became law as Chapter 5 of the Statutes of Ontario, 2021. Its stated goal is to protect Ontario elections; the changes include new election-finance rules, not a guarantee of any particular election outcome.

  • The Chief Electoral Officer must set up an advisory committee on voting and vote-counting equipment. The committee must include one or two members appointed by each registered party represented in the Assembly, plus one to three members who do not represent a party. It gives recommendations when the Chief Electoral Officer consults it.
  • The Chief Electoral Officer must set advance-poll dates and times at designated other locations, in consultation with the returning officer. At least one such location in each electoral district must be open for some part of each day during the 10-day period; schedules can differ by location.
  • Contribution limits are revised, including a $3,300 base limit that rises by $25 for each calendar year beginning in 2022. The bill also changes two other contribution figures, from $5,000 to $10,000 and from $25,000 to $50,000; the supplied text does not show enough surrounding law to identify exactly which limits those figures apply to.
  • Third-party political advertisers face expanded rules against coordinating to get around spending limits, and must report spending as it rises. The Chief Electoral Officer may order administrative penalties for listed breaches.
  • The bill allows independent MPPs to endorse constituency associations and gives eligible associations allowances. It also permits MPPs’ social-media accounts to carry partisan material, including during and after an election.
  • In municipal elections, clerks may allow electronic filing of nominations and third-party registrations. Required nomination endorsements must still have original signatures, and filers must retain the signed document.

What it means for you#

  • Voters: The bill sets rules for equipment advice and advance polling locations. It does not require a particular voting system or require every designated location to be open on all 10 days.
  • Political parties, candidates and donors: Contribution limits and some related rules change. Quarterly party allowances are set at $0.636 per valid vote per quarter and continued until January 1, 2025. An independent MPP’s registered association may qualify for an allowance based on the MPP’s share of votes; in some cases, the former party association also remains entitled to an allowance.
  • Third-party advertisers and advertising sellers: Advertisers must file interim reports when they pay or commit to spending on paid political ads, including each time total spending rises by at least $1,000, and when they reach their spending limit. The Chief Electoral Officer must publish reports within two days. An ad seller must not sell advertising if it should reasonably know the sale would push an advertiser over its limit.
  • MPP social-media users: An MPP may keep an individual social-media account through dissolution of the Assembly and an election, and may post partisan material, subject to applicable rules and laws. Ministers’ accounts are also subject to rules or guidelines approved by the Executive Council and public-service law.
  • Municipal candidates and third parties: Electronic filing is available only if the municipal clerk provides for it and may set conditions. A third party that files a nomination is treated as having withdrawn its third-party registration.
  • People or organizations subject to listed election-finance rules: The Chief Electoral Officer may impose an administrative penalty. The order can be appealed to the Superior Court of Justice within 30 days.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The bill requires quarterly allowances for registered parties through January 1, 2025, using the stated per-vote formula. It also provides allowances for some independent members’ constituency associations.
  • The Chief Electoral Officer must subsidize qualifying audit costs, up to $2,000 per audit.
  • Administrative penalties go into Ontario’s Consolidated Revenue Fund. The maximum depends on the breach: some penalties can reach $10,000 for an individual or $100,000 for an organization; other limits are lower or tied to the amount of an improper contribution.
  • The bill does not state the cost of the advisory committee, added reporting work or enforcement, or how many staff those tasks may require.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include the full parent Acts, so the existing rules and the exact baseline for all changed limits could not be verified.
  • The bill does not set out how the non-party members of the voting-equipment committee are chosen, or how the committee works beyond giving recommendations when consulted.
  • The phrase “common advocacy, cause or goal,” used in third-party coordination rules, is not defined in the supplied text.
  • The bill does not state how many administrative-penalty orders will be made or what resources enforcement will require.
  • It does not explain how the revised rules interact with other election programs or provide a full cost estimate.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give the Chief Electoral Officer advice on voting equipment while leaving decisions with that official.
  • Setting a minimum amount of advance polling access across a district could make polling schedules more predictable while allowing local flexibility.
  • Interim spending reports and limits on coordination could help disclose political advertising spending while it is happening, rather than only afterward.
  • Allowing electronic municipal filings where clerks choose to offer them could make filing more convenient, while retaining original nomination endorsements.
  • Explicit rules for MPP social-media accounts could clarify that accounts may continue through elections, while keeping them subject to other rules and laws.

Case against#

  • The bill gives the Chief Electoral Officer new reporting and enforcement work without stating the staffing or funding needed.
  • The third-party coordination rules cover several kinds of shared relationships and information, but the supplied text does not define some key terms. That may leave uncertainty about which conduct breaks the rules.
  • The Chief Electoral Officer can set penalty amounts within the limits, and the bill lists factors to consider; organizations and individuals may still face uncertainty about how those factors will be applied.
  • The bill continues and changes public allowances for parties and some independent members’ associations, but the available material does not estimate the total public cost.
  • Municipal electronic filing depends on each clerk choosing to offer it, so the option may not be available in every municipality.

Votes

4 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2021041501

    Passed48 members voted

    Motion for closure on the motion for Third Reading of Bill 254

    FOR · 32AGAINST · 16

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    32For

    • PC32

    16Against

    • NDP10
    • Liberal4
    • Green1
    • New Blue Party of Ontario1
  2. Division No. 2021041502

    Passed48 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 254

    FOR · 32AGAINST · 16

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    32For

    • PC32

    16Against

    • NDP10
    • Liberal4
    • Green1
    • New Blue Party of Ontario1
  3. Division No. 2021032201

    Passed73 members voted

    Motion for closure on Second Reading of Bill 254

    FOR · 41AGAINST · 32

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    41For

    • PC41

    32Against

    • NDP25
    • Liberal5
    • Green1
    • New Blue Party of Ontario1
  4. Division No. 2021032202

    Passed73 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 254

    FOR · 41AGAINST · 32

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    41For

    • PC41

    32Against

    • NDP25
    • Liberal5
    • Green1
    • New Blue Party of Ontario1