Summary#
Bill 58, the Delegated Administrative Authorities Accountability and Transparency Act, 2016, would amend several existing Ontario laws; it would not create a new administrative authority. Its stated goal is to increase accountability and transparency for authorities that administer laws on the government’s behalf.
- It would transfer certain board-appointment powers from ministers to the Lieutenant Governor in Council (the provincial Cabinet acting formally through the Lieutenant Governor).
- It would require annual audits by the Auditor General, paid for from each authority’s funds.
- It would make these authorities subject to Ontario’s access-to-information law and the Ombudsman Act.
- It would require public salary and benefits records for certain Cabinet-appointed board members paid at least $100,000 in salary.
- For some authorities, it would set rules for Cabinet-appointed board members, including limits on whether they can form a board majority. It would also state that the New Home Warranty Corporation, Ontario One Call and the designated wine authority are not Crown agents.
What it means for you#
- People dealing with these authorities: The bill would make the authorities subject to access-to-information and Ombudsman laws. This could give people routes to request records or raise complaints, subject to the laws’ rules and limits.
- Board members and authorities: Cabinet-appointed members of the New Home Warranty Corporation, Ontario One Call and the designated wine authority would be entitled to reasonable remuneration and expenses, paid by their authority. The bill also changes who appoints board members in several other authorities.
- Condominium owners, managers, new-home buyers, and other members of the public: The bill does not directly change the underlying services, protections, or responsibilities these laws provide. It changes oversight and governance of the authorities that administer them.
- Taxpayers: The bill does not set a tax, fee, fine, or new public benefit.
Money#
No total cost estimate is provided; the bill requires authorities to pay annual Auditor General audit costs from their own funds.
- The New Home Warranty Corporation, Ontario One Call and the designated wine authority would also have to provide reasonable remuneration and expenses to Cabinet-appointed board members.
- The bill gives no estimate for audit, board-payment, staffing, or other costs, and does not say whether any costs would affect fees or services.
What is unclear#
- The source does not include the parent Acts or current consolidated laws, so it is not possible to verify all changes against current law or identify later amendments.
- The bill does not set out how requests for records or complaints would be handled beyond applying the existing laws.
- Salary disclosure applies to Cabinet-appointed board members paid at least $100,000 in salary; the bill does not extend this specific disclosure rule to all board members.
- Board appointment rules differ across the amended laws. The bill does not impose the same stated limit on Cabinet appointees’ share of the board in every provision.
- The text provides for staged commencement of some changes, but the materials do not say whether the bill received Royal Assent or when those provisions took effect.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to strengthen oversight of authorities that administer laws on the government’s behalf.
- Annual Auditor General audits could provide an independent check of each authority’s accounts and financial transactions.
- Access-to-information and Ombudsman laws could give the public more ways to seek records or raise concerns about these authorities.
- Public salary disclosure for higher-paid Cabinet-appointed board members could make some payments more visible.
Case against#
- Audit and board-remuneration costs would be paid by the authorities, but the bill gives no cost estimates or explanation of possible effects on their resources.
- Moving appointment powers to Cabinet could increase the government’s influence over authority boards. The bill limits Cabinet appointees to less than a majority in some provisions, but the rules vary.
- Salary disclosure is limited to Cabinet-appointed board members paid at least $100,000 in salary, leaving other board compensation outside this specific requirement.
- The bill adds oversight rules but does not explain how the public would use them in practice or how they would affect existing authority processes.