Bill would audit authorities, reveal salaries

Summary#

Bill 56, the Delegated Administrative Authorities Accountability and Transparency Act, 2018, is an amending bill: it would change several existing Ontario laws governing delegated administrative authorities. Its stated goal, suggested by its title, is greater accountability and transparency; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result.

  • It would move some powers to appoint board members from ministers to the Lieutenant Governor in Council (the provincial cabinet acting formally through the Lieutenant Governor).
  • It would require annual audits of each covered authority’s accounts and financial transactions by the Auditor General. The authority would pay the audit cost.
  • It would make covered authorities subject to Ontario’s freedom-of-information law and the Ombudsman Act.
  • It would require public disclosure of salary and benefits for certain cabinet-appointed board members who receive at least $100,000 in salary.
  • For some authorities, it would allow cabinet appointments only if its appointees are less than a majority of the board. The bill also names possible appointees for some boards, including representatives of consumer groups, business, and government organizations.

The authorities covered include those responsible for condominium matters, new-home construction and warranties, underground infrastructure notifications, technical standards and safety, wine designations, and certain consumer statutes.

What it means for you#

  • People seeking information or help with a complaint: Covered authorities would become subject to freedom-of-information requests and the Ombudsman Act. The chair of each authority’s board would be its “head” for these laws.
  • Consumers, condominium owners, home buyers, businesses and others dealing with these authorities: The bill changes oversight and board appointments, but does not create a new front-line service or a new application or complaint process.
  • Board members and authority staff: Cabinet-appointed board members paid at least $100,000 in salary would have their salary and benefits disclosed. For certain authorities, existing minister-appointed board members’ appointments would be revoked 30 days after Royal Assent, if the relevant transition provisions apply.
  • Taxpayers and authority members or customers: The bill does not directly change taxes, fees, benefits, or property rights. Some authorities would have to pay for annual audits from their own funds.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill requires covered authorities to pay for annual Auditor General audits from their own funds.
  • Some authorities must provide reasonable remuneration and expenses to cabinet-appointed board members.
  • The bill gives no estimate of audit, staffing, or other costs, and does not say whether authorities would change their fees to cover them.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the full Acts being amended, so the exact existing appointment rules and how all changes fit with current law could not be verified.
  • Some provisions start only when provisions in other Acts come into force. The text does not establish which of those conditions would be met or when every change would take effect.
  • The bill does not set out how freedom-of-information requests or Ombudsman complaints would be handled in practice.
  • It does not explain how often the new disclosure rules would apply to each authority, beyond the stated annual reporting requirement and salary threshold.
  • The supplied material does not state the bill’s current status.

Case for#

  • Annual audits by the Auditor General could provide an independent check of authorities’ accounts and financial transactions.
  • Freedom-of-information and Ombudsman oversight could give people more ways to seek records or raise concerns about covered authorities.
  • Public disclosure could make payments to some cabinet-appointed board members easier to scrutinize.
  • Moving appointment powers to cabinet could make responsibility for board appointments clearer.

Case against#

  • Annual audits and added disclosure duties could cost authorities money; the bill provides no cost estimate.
  • Shifting appointment powers to cabinet could increase government influence over authorities. The bill limits cabinet appointees to less than a majority for some boards, but the supplied text does not set out that same limit for every authority.
  • The bill adds oversight, but does not explain the processes, timelines, or resources needed to handle information requests and Ombudsman complaints.
  • It is unclear whether the changes would create overlap with existing oversight or disclosure requirements.