Safer School Zones Act expands speed cameras

Summary#

The Safer School Zones Act, 2017 amends Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act. It was enacted as Chapter 9 of Ontario’s 2017 statutes, but its changes take effect only on a day set by proclamation; the supplied material gives no start date. Its stated goal is safer school zones.

  • Municipalities may set speeds below 50 km/h across a designated area, but must post signs; they may exclude roads with a different speed set by by-law.
  • Automated speed enforcement may be used in school zones and in community safety zones where the speed limit is below 80 km/h. The bill allows this; it does not require municipalities to install cameras.
  • The bill sets rules limiting some consequences of camera-based speeding convictions: an owner convicted through automated speed enforcement cannot have their licence suspended for not paying the fine, and a driver convicted this way cannot be jailed or given probation for the offence or for not paying the fine.
  • The Registrar may require number plates to be returned and cancel them if they are not returned on time. The deadline is 30 days for plates that may not photograph accurately because of their condition, and 60 days for other plates.
  • The bill removes the requirement that red-light cameras be used only in areas designated by regulation. It also transfers some regulation-making powers for red-light camera rules from the Lieutenant Governor in Council to the Minister.

What it means for you#

  • Municipalities: They may create lower-speed areas on roads that would otherwise have a 50 km/h limit. Signs are required before a by-law takes effect. They may also choose to use automated speed enforcement in the specified zones.
  • Drivers and vehicle owners: A camera-based speeding offence may lead to a conviction, subject to rules set by regulation. The bill limits the consequences of unpaid fines as described above. It does not require cameras to be used in every eligible zone.
  • Number-plate holders: If the Registrar requires a plate to be returned, it must be returned by the required date to avoid possible cancellation. The Registrar may give notice by personal delivery or mail to the holder’s latest address on Ministry records. There is no right to be heard before that notice is given.
  • Drivers generally: The bill prohibits obstructing a number plate with a device that prevents the whole plate, including its numbers, from being accurately photographed by automated speed enforcement.
  • Red-light camera rules: The change removes a provincial restriction on where the systems may be used; it does not require their use in any particular place.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s costs.

  • The bill sets no budget, cost estimate, fee, or fine amount.
  • It does not specify staffing or equipment costs for municipalities or the province.

What is unclear#

  • The proclamation date that brings the changes into force is not provided.
  • Regulations may set important details for automated speed enforcement, including how evidence is handled and what procedures apply. The bill does not provide those detailed rules.
  • The bill does not say how many municipalities will use cameras, where they will be placed, or how the programs will be run.
  • The full Highway Traffic Act was not supplied, so the changes could not be checked against every current-law provision.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives municipalities a way to set lower speeds across designated areas, rather than only on individual roads.
  • It allows speed enforcement in school zones and qualifying community safety zones, where the stated subject of the bill is speed safety.
  • The limits on licence suspension, imprisonment, and probation for camera-based convictions distinguish those penalties from the camera-based process.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill leaves key enforcement and court-process rules to future regulations, including rules about when a person is treated as not wishing to dispute a charge.
  • The bill does not set out where cameras will be used, how their use will be overseen, or what happens to the information they collect.
  • Municipalities may face equipment and operating costs, but the supplied material does not estimate them.

Votes

4 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 2017053004

    Passed92 members voted

    Motion for closure on Third Reading of Bill 65

    FOR · 52AGAINST · 40

    52For

    • Liberal52

    40Against

    • PC23
    • NDP16
    • Independent1
  2. Division No. 2017053005

    Passed93 members voted

    Third Reading of Bill 65

    FOR · 92AGAINST · 1

    92For

    • Liberal52
    • PC23
    • NDP17

    1Against

    • Independent1
  3. Division No. 2017041101

    Passed92 members voted

    Motion for closure on Second Reading of Bill 65

    FOR · 51AGAINST · 41

    51For

    • Liberal51

    41Against

    • PC24
    • NDP17
  4. Division No. 2017041102

    Passed92 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 65

    FOR · 68AGAINST · 24

    68For

    • Liberal51
    • NDP17

    24Against

    • PC24