School bus cameras prove offences

Summary#

Bill 94, the Highway Traffic Amendment Act (School Bus Camera Systems), 2017, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act. Its stated goal is to allow photographs and videos from school bus camera systems to be used as evidence in cases about failing to stop for a school bus.

  • A photograph or video that meets requirements set by regulation must be received as evidence in a case about the offences described in the bill.
  • Unless there is evidence to the contrary, a certified image can prove it came from a school bus camera system. An image can also count as proof of information shown on it and of the alleged failure to stop and wait.
  • The bill allows regulations to set camera-system, image, court-filing, offence-notice service, vehicle-ownership and driver-identity rules.
  • The bill does not require school buses to have cameras or create a new fine. It would take effect on a date set by proclamation.

What it means for you#

  • Drivers accused of the offences: Camera images could be used in proceedings about failing to stop for a school bus and proceeding before the bus moves or its red signal-lights stop flashing. The bill describes one of the alleged offences as failing to stop at least 20 metres before reaching the bus. The image-based proof rules can be challenged with evidence to the contrary.
  • Drivers pleading not guilty at trial: The bill says a person cannot be convicted on the basis of a camera image unless it is presented as evidence at trial.
  • Courts and provincial offences officers: Courts would have to receive qualifying images as evidence. A provincial offences officer’s certificate would, unless evidence shows otherwise, establish that an image came from a school bus camera system.
  • School bus operators and the public: The bill does not require camera installation or set out an application or review process. It does not directly change the stop rules themselves, but the supplied material does not include the current Highway Traffic Act to verify how those rules operate today.

Money#

No cost information is in the supplied material.

  • The bill gives the Lieutenant Governor in Council power to make regulations, but no staffing, implementation or court-administration costs are estimated.
  • No fees, fines, or new spending are specified in the bill.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set a start date; it would begin on a date named by proclamation.
  • The regulations that would define camera systems and set image requirements are not supplied. The bill does not itself specify what equipment qualifies.
  • Regulations may set rules for filing images, serving offence notices and proving vehicle ownership or driver identity. The details are not in the bill.
  • The Highway Traffic Act provisions that the bill says would apply “with necessary modifications” are not supplied, so their effect and the bill’s relationship to current procedures could not be checked.
  • No publicly available information on implementation costs is included in the supplied material.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that camera images could provide evidence in cases about drivers failing to stop for school buses.
  • Requiring images to meet rules set by regulation could allow common standards for what they show and how they are filed.
  • The proof rules are not absolute: evidence to the contrary can challenge what an image or officer’s certificate establishes.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill lets an image count as proof of key facts unless there is evidence to the contrary. The bill does not explain how accused drivers would obtain or challenge the underlying camera material.
  • Regulations could affect image requirements, notice service and proof of ownership or driver identity, but those rules are not included. This leaves important procedures unsettled in the bill.
  • The bill does not estimate the cost of setting up or administering the process, or explain who would bear those costs.