Auditor General Expands Contractor Audits

Summary#

Bill 67, the Auditor General Amendment Act, 2016, would amend Ontario’s existing Auditor General Act. Its stated goal is to let the Auditor General conduct special audits of public contractors.

  • It defines a public contractor as an entity that delivers programs or services on behalf of the Crown and either receives Crown-related payments or financial assistance, directly or indirectly, or is empowered by the Crown to collect fees for those services.
  • The Auditor General may conduct a special audit of a public contractor; the bill does not require an audit of every contractor.
  • The Auditor General would be entitled to free access to records and other property belonging to or used by a contractor if the Auditor General believes they are needed for duties under the Act. That access applies despite any other Act.
  • The bill also adds public contractors to other provisions of the Auditor General Act. Without that Act’s text, the effects of those additions cannot be verified.
  • The bill would start on Royal Assent. It creates no new agency.

What it means for you#

  • Organizations delivering Crown programs or services: If they meet the bill’s definition, their relevant records and property could be subject to the Auditor General’s access for the Auditor General’s duties. The bill does not say every such organization will be audited.
  • Auditor General: Would gain the power to conduct special audits of public contractors and the stated access to their records and property.
  • Individuals and other businesses: The bill does not directly change individual benefits, taxes, fees, or services.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill authorizes a new type of special audit but gives no cost estimate or staffing details.
  • It does not set a fee or provide an appropriation in the text supplied.

What is unclear#

  • The definition covers indirect financial support and several forms of Crown-related payments, but the bill does not explain how borderline cases would be decided.
  • The bill does not set out how audits are selected, how they are carried out, or what notice or review process applies.
  • The bill changes other sections of the Auditor General Act, but that Act was not supplied, so the added duties or rules in those sections cannot be verified against current law.
  • The supplied material does not state the bill’s status or whether it received Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to let the Auditor General examine public services delivered outside government when public money or Crown-authorized fees are involved.
  • Access to records could help the Auditor General examine how those services are delivered and supported.
  • Applying the power to direct and indirect funding could reduce gaps where a contractor receives money through another recipient.

Case against#

  • The definition may cover a wide range of entities, including those receiving indirect support or collecting user fees under Crown authority.
  • The Auditor General’s access applies despite any other Act, while the bill itself does not explain how that power would interact with other rules or what safeguards would apply.
  • The bill gives the Auditor General discretion to conduct special audits but does not state how the choice would be made or how much the expanded work could cost.