Auditor General Amendment Act Expands Access

Summary#

Bill 19, the Auditor General Amendment Act, 2022, would amend Ontario’s Auditor General Act by replacing two rules about providing information and access to records. Its stated purpose is to let the Auditor General obtain information needed to do the job even when it is confidential or protected by certain privileges; that is a goal, not a guaranteed result.

  • Ministries, Crown agencies, Crown-controlled corporations and grant recipients would have to give the Auditor General information the Auditor General believes is necessary for the Auditor General’s duties.
  • That duty would apply even to confidential information and information subject to solicitor-client, litigation or settlement privilege.
  • The Auditor General would be entitled to free access to records, data, papers, things or property belonging to or used by those organizations, when the Auditor General believes they are necessary.
  • That access would apply despite privacy, confidentiality or privilege rights, including public interest immunity.

What it means for you#

  • Ministries, Crown agencies, Crown-controlled corporations and grant recipients: You would have to provide relevant information and access to records or other property, including some material that would otherwise be confidential or privileged.
  • Auditor General: The bill would give the Auditor General an express right to this information and access, subject to the Auditor General believing it is necessary for duties under the Act.
  • General public: The bill does not itself change benefits, taxes, or the public’s right to see records. It addresses access by the Auditor General. The supplied text does not say that material obtained must be made public.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require the named organizations and grant recipients to provide information and access. The time, staffing and other costs of doing so are not estimated.
  • The bill does not set a fee, fine, new grant, or specific spending amount.

What is unclear#

  • The parent Auditor General Act was not supplied, so the exact difference from current law and any existing safeguards could not be verified.
  • The bill does not define “grant recipient” in the supplied text, so the full range of organizations covered is unclear.
  • It does not set out a process for disputes over whether information is necessary, or timelines for providing it.
  • The supplied text does not explain how privileged or confidential material must be handled, protected or disclosed after access.
  • The bill would start on Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not establish whether it has become law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to prevent confidentiality or privilege claims from blocking the Auditor General from information needed for an audit.
  • Giving access to records and information held by the named organizations could help the Auditor General examine their activities and financial transactions.
  • The Auditor General’s judgment that material is necessary provides a stated limit on the access power.

Case against#

  • The bill would require access even to solicitor-client and other privileged material, which could affect the confidentiality people and organizations normally expect for that material.
  • The bill does not set out a dispute process or specific handling rules for sensitive material.
  • “Grant recipient” is not defined in the supplied text, leaving uncertainty about how widely the duty would apply.
  • The bill provides no estimate of the workload or costs for the organizations that must respond.