Summary#
Bill 75, the Putting Voters First (Election Amendment) Act, 2016, would amend Ontario’s Election Act. Its stated goal is to prohibit people from seeking or accepting a bribe to become, not become, or withdraw as an election candidate.
- It would add a new item to section 96.1 covering applying for, accepting, or agreeing to accept valuable consideration, an office, or employment in connection with those candidacy decisions.
- The supplied explanatory note describes this as a prohibition. The bill text provided does not include the surrounding wording of section 96.1, so its exact legal effect in that section cannot be checked here.
- It would take effect on Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- People involved in candidacy decisions: The change is aimed at a person seeking or accepting something valuable in connection with agreeing to become a candidate, refraining from becoming one, or withdrawing. The precise people covered depends on the rest of section 96.1.
- Voters: The bill does not directly change voting rules or voter eligibility.
- Employers and others offering an office or employment: The added wording refers to an office or employment, but the supplied text does not set out a separate duty or penalty for the person offering it.
Money#
No publicly available information on costs is included in the supplied material.
- The bill gives no estimate for enforcement or other public costs.
- No fee, tax, fine, or spending is set out in the supplied text.
What is unclear#
- The Election Act itself was not supplied, so I could not verify what section 96.1 already prohibits or how this addition would fit with current law.
- The bill does not define “valuable consideration.”
- The supplied material does not say what penalty or other consequence would apply, or who would enforce the provision.
- It does not explain how the rule would apply in particular cases, such as what counts as being “in connection with” a candidacy decision.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to prevent people from being induced with something valuable to enter, avoid, or leave an election race.
- A possible argument for the bill is that naming these candidacy decisions in the Election Act makes clear that seeking or accepting valuable consideration in connection with them is prohibited.
Case against#
- One concern is that “valuable consideration” is not defined in the supplied text, leaving the scope of the rule unclear.
- The bill text provided does not show the existing section’s wording or the consequences for breaking the rule. Readers therefore cannot tell from these materials how the prohibition would work in practice.