Election fundraising transparency bill cracks down on reimbursements

Summary#

Bill 85, the Election Fundraising Transparency Act, 2019, would amend Ontario’s Election Finances Act; it would not create a separate law or agency. Its stated goal, reflected in its title, is greater fundraising transparency. The bill says it would start on Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not say whether it passed.

  • A person would be prohibited from knowingly accepting or receiving a third-party reimbursement for money they contributed to a registered political party, constituency association, nomination contestant, candidate or leadership contestant.
  • A person making a contribution covered by section 18 of the Election Finances Act would have to certify, when making it, that they have not acted contrary to subsection 19(1) and will not be reimbursed by a third party.
  • The certification would have to use a form approved by the Chief Electoral Officer.
  • The bill does not directly prohibit a third party from offering or providing reimbursement; its prohibition is on knowingly accepting or receiving it.

What it means for you#

  • People making political contributions: If your contribution is one covered by section 18, you would have to provide the required certification at the time you contribute. The bill does not provide the form.
  • People receiving contributions: Knowingly accepting or receiving a third-party reimbursement for your contribution to one of the listed registered political entities would be prohibited.
  • Third parties: The bill does not directly set out a prohibition on offering or providing reimbursement. It prohibits the recipient from knowingly accepting or receiving it.
  • Political entities and the public: The bill does not directly change who may contribute, contribution limits, or public funding. The supplied material does not allow those rules to be checked against current law.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The required certification would use a form approved by the Chief Electoral Officer. No cost estimate or staffing details are provided.
  • The bill does not set a fee, fine, tax, or benefit.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include sections 18 or 19 of the current Election Finances Act. So it is not possible to verify which contributions require certification or what subsection 19(1) prohibits.
  • The bill does not define “reimbursement” or “third party.”
  • The bill does not set out how the certification would be collected or checked, or what process would apply if someone breached the rules.
  • The bill itself does not specify a penalty for a breach. The supplied material does not show whether other parts of the Act provide one.
  • The supplied material does not say whether the bill passed.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that requiring contributors to certify they will not be reimbursed could discourage people from disguising who ultimately paid for a political contribution.
  • The prohibition on knowingly accepting a reimbursement would address the recipient’s conduct, while the certification would require contributors to affirm their position when they give.
  • Using a form approved by the Chief Electoral Officer could make the certification process consistent.

Case against#

  • The bill directly prohibits accepting or receiving reimbursement, but does not directly prohibit a third party from offering or providing it. That may leave part of the arrangement outside this bill’s express prohibition.
  • The bill does not define reimbursement or explain how to handle disputed cases, making the scope of the rule unclear.
  • The bill requires certification but does not explain how it would be checked or enforced. The available text also gives no cost estimate for administering it.
  • The certification refers to a separate rule in subsection 19(1), which is not included in the supplied material.