Summary#
Bill 164, the Human Rights Code Amendment Act, 2017, would amend Ontario’s existing Human Rights Code. Its stated goal is to add immigration status, genetic characteristics, police records and social condition as grounds protected from discrimination. It would take effect on Royal Assent.
- People would have a right to equal treatment on those grounds in services, goods and facilities, housing, contracts, employment and membership in certain organizations.
- The bill defines immigration status by reference to Canadian immigration law. It defines police records to include charges, convictions and contact with police, and defines social condition by reference to certain social or economic disadvantages.
- Protection based on genetic characteristics would include refusing to take a genetic test or refusing to disclose or authorize disclosure of its results.
- The bill would also change existing Code provisions and exceptions, including provisions about citizenship and references to “record of offences.” The supplied material does not include the full Code needed to verify the effect of each change.
What it means for you#
- People seeking or receiving services, housing, contracts or organizational membership: The bill would add the four grounds to equal-treatment protections in these areas. The bill does not set out new application, review or appeal procedures.
- Workers and employers: The bill would add the four grounds to employment protections, including protection from workplace harassment on those grounds.
- People with police records: The proposed definition includes charges and convictions, with or without a record suspension, and records of contact with police. The bill does not say that every decision based on such information would be unlawful; it also changes existing exceptions.
- People asked to take or disclose genetic tests: The bill would protect equal treatment when a person refuses. It does not ban genetic testing.
- Government and taxpayers: The bill changes the Code’s protections and related provisions; it does not create a new agency or a separate benefit program.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The bill does not provide an estimate for public spending, staffing, enforcement or compliance costs.
What is unclear#
- The full Human Rights Code was not supplied, so I could not verify how these changes would interact with current protections or the precise effect of all amended exceptions.
- The bill does not define “genetic characteristics.” Its definition of social condition includes “any other circumstance similar” to the listed examples, without explaining how similarity would be judged.
- Because “police records” includes police contact, the definition is broad; the bill does not explain how the term would apply in particular situations.
- The bill changes existing provisions on citizenship, disability and exceptions, but the supplied material does not show enough of those provisions to explain the full limits on the new protections.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address unequal treatment based on circumstances not listed as protected grounds in the Code’s described current wording.
- Adding protections across services, housing, employment and other areas could give people a common legal basis to challenge discrimination in different parts of life.
- Explicitly protecting refusal to take or disclose a genetic test could help prevent unequal treatment based on a person’s decision to keep that information private.
Case against#
- The bill uses broad or undefined terms, including “genetic characteristics” and the open-ended part of “social condition,” leaving important boundaries unclear.
- Including police contact, charges and convictions in “police records” makes the protected ground broad. The bill does not explain how that protection would interact with the exceptions it also amends.
- The supplied material gives no cost estimate and does not explain how the existing Code process would handle claims based on the new grounds.