Judges to Receive Sexual Assault Law Training

Summary#

Bill 9, the Mandatory Sexual Assault Law Training for Judicial Officers Act, 2018, would amend Ontario’s Courts of Justice Act and Justices of the Peace Act. Its stated goal is to require sexual-assault-law education for provincial judges and justices of the peace, both before appointment and as part of continuing education. The supplied material does not say whether the bill passed; this summary describes what it would do if enacted.

  • Judicial appointment committees could not consider a provincial judge or justice of the peace candidate unless the relevant committee was satisfied that the candidate had completed recent, comprehensive education in sexual assault law.
  • That education would have to cover evidentiary prohibitions, consent, how sexual assault proceedings are conducted, and myths and stereotypes about sexual assault complainants.
  • Existing continuing-education plans would have to require judges and justices of the peace to complete education on those topics.
  • The appointment requirements would start on Royal Assent. The continuing-education requirements would start six months after Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • People applying to become provincial judges or justices of the peace: The relevant committee could not consider your candidacy without being satisfied that you had completed the required education.
  • Judges and justices of the peace: Their continuing-education plans would have to require education on sexual assault law and the listed topics.
  • People involved in court cases: The bill does not directly change court procedures, evidence rules, or the rights of parties. It requires education about some of those matters; it does not guarantee a particular result in any case.
  • Appointment committees and those responsible for education plans: They would have to apply the new education requirements. The bill does not set out a process for choosing courses or checking ongoing compliance.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost.

  • The bill requires education for candidates and ongoing education for judges and justices of the peace, but gives no cost estimate, funding source, or staffing figure.
  • It does not set a fee or make a direct payment to candidates or judicial officers.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “recent” or “comprehensive,” or set a minimum course length or standard.
  • It leaves the appointment committees to decide whether a candidate’s education is satisfactory. It does not specify what evidence candidates must provide or whether there is a way to challenge a decision.
  • It does not state how often current judges and justices of the peace must take the education, who will provide it, or how completion will be tracked.
  • The Courts of Justice Act and Justices of the Peace Act were not supplied, so the existing provisions and any interaction with current training rules could not be independently checked against those Acts.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that judicial officers who hear sexual assault cases should receive education on the applicable evidence rules, consent, and court proceedings.
  • Requiring education about myths and stereotypes could help set a common baseline for candidates and serving judicial officers.
  • Making the education a condition for consideration would make it a requirement, rather than optional preparation for candidates.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define what counts as recent or comprehensive education, leaving important standards to the appointment committees and education plans.
  • It does not specify course providers, costs, frequency, or how compliance will be checked. Those details could affect how consistently the requirement is applied.
  • Candidates who have not completed education accepted by the committee could not be considered, but the bill does not explain how they could meet the requirement or challenge a committee’s decision.