Mandatory sexual assault training for judges bill

Summary#

Bill 120, Mandatory Sexual Assault Law Training for Judicial Officers Act, 2017, would amend Ontario’s Courts of Justice Act and Justices of the Peace Act. It would add sexual-assault-law education conditions for candidates for judge or justice of the peace, and require ongoing education for judges and justices of the peace. Its stated goal, reflected in its title, is to make this training mandatory.

  • The judicial and justices-of-the-peace advisory committees could not consider a candidate who had not completed recent, comprehensive sexual-assault-law education to the committee’s satisfaction.
  • That education would have to cover rules limiting the use of evidence, consent, how sexual-assault cases are conducted, and myths and stereotypes about complainants.
  • Plans for judges’ and justices of the peace’s continuing education would have to require education on matters related to sexual assault law, including those same topics.
  • The appointment-related requirements would start when the bill received Royal Assent. The continuing-education requirements would start six months later.

What it means for you#

  • People seeking appointment as a provincial judge or justice of the peace: The relevant committee could not consider your candidacy unless you had completed the required education to its satisfaction. The bill does not say how recent the education must be or how a candidate proves completion.
  • Judges and justices of the peace: Their continuing-education plans would have to require them to complete education on sexual-assault-law matters, including the listed topics. The bill does not set the course length, format, or completion schedule.
  • Members of the public: The bill would change appointment and continuing-education requirements. It does not create a new court, change the legal rules for deciding sexual-assault cases, or require a particular outcome in any case.
  • Current process: The supplied explanatory note says the Judicial Appointments Advisory Committee already recommends provincial judges to the Attorney General. The bill adds a condition for considering candidates; it does not replace that committee process.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill requires continuing-education plans to include mandatory education, but gives no cost estimate or funding source.
  • It does not say who would pay for the education or how much staff time committees would need.

What is unclear#

  • “Recent” and “comprehensive” are not defined. The bill also does not set a standard for what would satisfy either committee.
  • The bill does not specify who would provide the education, how it would be delivered, or how completion would be checked.
  • It does not set the amount or timing of continuing education, beyond requiring it to be included in the plans.
  • The supplied material does not explain how these requirements would relate to any existing training or education requirements.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to ensure that candidates for judicial office have education on sexual-assault law before committees consider them.
  • Requiring continuing education as well as education for candidates could make the requirement apply to both new and current judicial officers.
  • Listing evidence rules, consent, court proceedings, and myths and stereotypes gives the education plan specific topics to cover.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves key standards—such as what counts as “recent” or “comprehensive”—to the committees, without stating how they should apply them.
  • It requires education but does not set a course format, length, or assessment. The bill therefore does not ensure that training will be consistent or that participants will meet a stated standard.
  • The bill gives no cost estimate or funding plan, even though it requires education to be added to continuing-education plans.