Summary#
Bill 121, the Courts of Justice Amendment Act (Judicial Sexual Assault Education), 2017, would amend Ontario’s Courts of Justice Act. Its stated goal is to require sexual-assault education or training for candidates for provincial judge appointments; the supplied material does not say whether the bill became law.
- The Judicial Appointments Advisory Committee could not consider a candidate unless the candidate met the bill’s experience requirement and had completed the required education or training.
- The experience requirement is at least 10 years as a member of a Canadian provincial or territorial bar, or an aggregate of at least 10 years as a bar member or as a judge in Canada after becoming a bar member.
- The training must be comprehensive and meet Committee criteria covering evidence law in sexual-assault proceedings, consent, how those proceedings are conducted, and myths and stereotypes about complainants.
- No person could be appointed as a provincial judge without completing that training.
What it means for you#
- People applying to be provincial judges: You would have to complete qualifying training before the Committee could consider you. The bill does not say who provides the training or how candidates obtain it.
- Judicial Appointments Advisory Committee: It would set criteria for the required training and could not consider candidates who had not completed training meeting those criteria.
- People involved in sexual-assault cases and the general public: The bill changes requirements for provincial judge candidates. It does not require current judges to take training, or create a new court service or a process for reviewing cases.
- The bill’s start date: It says it would come into force on Royal Assent. The supplied material does not establish whether that happened.
Money#
No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.
- The bill requires candidates to complete training but does not say who would provide or pay for it.
- It sets no fee, fine, appropriation or staffing amount.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define “comprehensive” training or set its length, provider, format, or timing.
- It leaves the training criteria to the Judicial Appointments Advisory Committee; the supplied material does not give those criteria.
- It does not say how completion would be confirmed or whether there would be exceptions.
- The parent Act was not supplied, so I could not verify the current qualification and appointment rules against the full Act or assess how the amendment would fit with them.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to ensure provincial judge candidates have education on the law and conduct of sexual-assault proceedings before appointment.
- Requiring coverage of evidence, consent, and myths and stereotypes makes the training address several distinct issues that can arise in these cases.
- Leaving criteria to the Judicial Appointments Advisory Committee could allow it to set standards for what counts as suitable training.
Case against#
- The bill does not set a minimum course length or detailed training standards, so the required preparation could depend heavily on criteria set later by the Committee.
- It does not explain who would provide or pay for training, or how candidates would show they completed it.
- The bill requires training for candidates but does not require ongoing education for judges after appointment.