Bill preserves hospital gift rules

Summary#

The Kingston Health Sciences Centre Act, 2018 is a special Ontario law about gifts and other property intended for Kingston General Hospital or Hotel Dieu Hospital. It treats those gifts as going to Kingston Health Sciences Centre (KHSC), or to the University Hospitals Kingston Foundation for KHSC’s benefit, while preserving limits on how the property may be used. The stated goal is to preserve the purposes attached to gifts after the hospitals integrated.

  • Gifts, trusts, bequests, devises and grants intended for either former hospital are legally treated as gifts to KHSC.
  • Gifts to the Foundation for either hospital’s benefit are treated as gifts to the Foundation for KHSC’s benefit.
  • KHSC must use property intended for Kingston General Hospital only for purposes in that hospital’s letters patent in effect on March 31, 2017.
  • KHSC must use property intended for Hotel Dieu Hospital only for purposes in its letters patent in effect on that date, and consistently with obligations tied to its Catholic religious affiliation and health care. The Act refers to the Catholic Health Alliance of Canada’s Health Ethics Guide, as it may be amended.
  • These rules apply to gifts made before or after the Act comes into force. They remain subject to any restrictions or directions in the gift’s terms.

What it means for you#

  • Donors, people making wills, and other gift-makers: A gift intended for either former hospital is treated as going to KHSC. The Act preserves the gift’s applicable purpose limits; it does not say those limits are removed.
  • The Foundation: It continues to receive gifts intended for the former hospitals, but those gifts are treated as being for KHSC’s benefit.
  • KHSC: It must use affected property for the applicable purposes and obligations described in the Act and in the gift’s terms.
  • Patients and the public: The Act concerns gifts and their permitted use. It does not directly change patient eligibility, hospital services, or how care is delivered.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The Act transfers no stated amount of money and sets no tax, fee, or fine.
  • It does not provide an estimate for any administrative or other costs of applying its rules.

What is unclear#

  • The Act does not include the former hospitals’ letters patent, so their listed purposes cannot be checked from the supplied material.
  • It does not explain how KHSC will track gifts, confirm compliance with their restrictions, or resolve disputes about their terms.
  • It refers to the Health Ethics Guide “as amended from time to time,” but the supplied material does not give the guide’s contents or explain how later amendments would affect the use of a particular gift.

Case for#

  • The hospitals integrated before this Act. Treating gifts as directed to KHSC may allow property intended for the former hospitals to be used by the integrated health centre.
  • Preserving purpose restrictions and directions in gift terms helps maintain the limits attached by donors.
  • Keeping Hotel Dieu’s stated religious obligations in place may protect the purposes and conditions associated with gifts intended for that hospital.

Case against#

  • The law applies to gifts made before it comes into force. One concern is that applying the new legal treatment to earlier gift documents could raise questions about how their terms are interpreted.
  • The Act does not set out a process for checking or enforcing compliance with gift restrictions.
  • The Hotel Dieu provisions refer to a guide that may change over time; the Act does not explain how future changes to the guide affect the use of gifts.