Museum Tax Relief for Kingston Land

Summary#

Bill PR51, the Marine Museum of the Great Lakes at Kingston Act (Tax Relief), 2016, would create a separate Ontario law. Its stated goal is to grant tax relief for specified land leased by the museum at 55 Ontario Street in Kingston, for January 29 to August 23, 2016.

  • Kingston City Council may pass a by-law exempting the specified property from municipal taxes for that period, or cancelling taxes already levied for all or part of it. Local improvement rates are excluded.
  • If the city passes an exemption by-law, the property is also exempt from school taxes for the same period. If the city cancels municipal taxes, school taxes, interest and penalties are also cancelled for the matching period.
  • Any part occupied and used by another entity is not covered by the exemption or cancellations.
  • The law would take effect on Royal Assent, but the relief would apply to the stated 2016 period. The bill itself does not grant relief automatically: the city must choose whether to pass a by-law.

What it means for you#

  • The museum: It may receive relief from municipal and school taxes for the specified property and period, but only if the city passes the relevant by-law. The bill does not promise that it will.
  • Kingston City Council: The city may exempt or cancel the covered municipal taxes. It is not required to do so.
  • School-tax recipients and other taxpayers: If the city grants relief, school taxes for the same period would also be exempted or cancelled. The bill does not say how that change would affect individual tax bills or budgets.
  • Other occupants: A portion occupied and used by another entity is not eligible for the bill’s tax relief.
  • Property owners generally: The bill concerns only specifically described land leased by this museum. It does not change tax rules for other properties.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the available material.

  • The bill could reduce municipal and school tax revenue, and cancel related interest and penalties, if the city passes a by-law.
  • Local improvement rates remain payable under the bill.
  • The bill says the Municipal Act, 2001 rules on taxes collected for other bodies apply to cancelled school taxes. It gives no estimate of any resulting costs or payments.
  • No staffing or administrative cost estimate is provided.

What is unclear#

  • Whether Kingston City Council would pass either by-law is not stated.
  • The preamble describes the land as used solely by the museum during the period, but the operative rules do not make that description an express eligibility test. They do exclude portions occupied and used by another entity.
  • The bill does not set out a process for requesting, deciding or reviewing the city’s by-law decision.
  • It does not say how much tax, interest or penalties were levied, or what amounts could be cancelled.
  • The bill does not explain how the Municipal Act chargeback rules would apply in this case.

Case for#

  • The bill would provide targeted relief for a named museum, a specific property and a limited past period.
  • The preamble says the museum is a registered charity and describes its purpose as studying, exhibiting and preserving the maritime heritage of Kingston and the Great Lakes.
  • The city would retain discretion over whether to grant municipal relief, while the bill limits relief for portions used by another entity.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that the tax relief could support the museum’s stated heritage purpose without changing tax treatment for other properties.

Case against#

  • The bill could reduce municipal and school tax revenue, but gives no estimate of the amounts.
  • The city’s decision is discretionary, and the bill sets no decision criteria or review process.
  • The preamble describes the museum’s charitable status and use of the land, but the operative rules do not clearly make those facts conditions for relief.
  • The law would provide relief for a past period without stating why the taxes should be exempted or cancelled.