Bill seeks to ban hydraulic fracturing

Summary#

Bill 110, the Oil, Gas and Salt Resources Amendment Act (Anti-Fracking), 2019, would amend Ontario’s Oil, Gas and Salt Resources Act. Its stated goal is to prohibit hydraulic fracturing and related activities for exploring for or producing oil or gas trapped in shale.

  • If enacted, it would prohibit anyone from carrying out those activities, despite anything in the amended Act or another Act.
  • The ban would not apply to an activity otherwise authorized under the Act if the Minister had granted a licence or permit for it by the day the amendment comes into force.
  • The bill adds contravening the ban to subsection 19(1) of the Act. The supplied material does not show what penalty or other consequence that subsection sets out.
  • The amendment would start on Royal Assent (the formal approval that makes a bill law).

What it means for you#

  • Oil and gas operators: If enacted, you could not carry out hydraulic fracturing or related activities to explore for or produce oil or gas trapped in shale, unless the stated existing-permit exception applies.
  • Operators with existing licences or permits: The exception applies only if the activity is otherwise authorized under the Act and the Minister granted a licence or permit for it on or before the amendment’s start date.
  • Other residents and businesses: The bill does not directly change taxes, benefits, or property rights. It does not ban hydraulic fracturing for purposes outside shale oil or gas exploration and production.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not specify public spending, staffing, fees, or compensation.
  • It gives no estimate of costs to operators of complying with the ban or of the financial effects of the exception.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the current Oil, Gas and Salt Resources Act. I cannot verify the existing rules or the penalties and enforcement consequences in subsection 19(1).
  • The bill does not define “activities related to hydraulic fracturing.”
  • It does not explain how authorities would decide whether a particular activity is related to hydraulic fracturing or is for shale oil or gas exploration or production.
  • The bill does not say how the exception would apply if a licence or permit covers more than one activity.
  • The supplied material does not establish the bill’s current status. Its text says it would start on Royal Assent if enacted.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would set a clear legal limit on hydraulic fracturing for shale oil or gas exploration and production.
  • The exception would preserve activities that were already authorized under the Act with a Minister-granted licence or permit by the start date.
  • The ban would apply despite provisions in other Acts, which could make its reach clearer where laws conflict.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define “activities related to hydraulic fracturing,” so the boundary of the ban may be unclear.
  • The exception means the bill would not stop activities covered by qualifying licences or permits granted before it starts.
  • The bill text alone does not show what penalty would apply or how the ban would be enforced.
  • The supplied material gives no cost estimate or explanation of the effects on operators or government.