Fracking ban would bar shale oil exploration

Summary#

Bill 130, the Oil, Gas and Salt Resources Amendment Act (Anti-Fracking), 2023, would amend Ontario’s Oil, Gas and Salt Resources Act. It would prohibit hydraulic fracturing and related activities to explore for or produce oil or gas trapped in shale, with an exception for certain activities already covered by a licence or permit. Its stated goal is to prohibit those activities.

  • The ban would apply despite anything in the Oil, Gas and Salt Resources Act or another Act.
  • The exception covers an activity authorized under the Act if the Minister granted a licence or permit for it on or before the new law takes effect.
  • The bill would add contravening the ban to subsection 19(1) of the Act. The supplied text does not show what consequences that subsection sets out.
  • The bill would start on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Oil and gas operators, and others carrying out the activities: If the bill became law, they could not engage in hydraulic fracturing or related activities to explore for or produce oil or gas trapped in shale, unless the exception applies.
  • Holders of existing licences or permits: The ban would not apply to an activity authorized under the Act if a licence or permit for that activity was granted by the Minister before the law takes effect. The exception is tied to the activity and its authorization.
  • People not involved in those activities: The bill does not directly change other oil and gas activity, or prohibit hydraulic fracturing for purposes outside the stated shale oil or gas exploration and production purpose.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s costs.

  • The bill does not state an amount for public spending, staffing, enforcement costs, fees, or savings.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “activities related to hydraulic fracturing” or “trapped in shale.”
  • The supplied material does not include the full existing Act, so the consequences of adding a breach to subsection 19(1), including any penalty, cannot be verified.
  • The bill does not set out how officials would determine whether an activity falls within the ban or the existing-permit exception.
  • No publicly available information on the bill’s current status.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to stop hydraulic fracturing and related activities for shale oil or gas exploration and production.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that a direct prohibition, applying despite other Acts, would set a clear legal limit on those activities.
  • The existing-licence exception could protect activities that were already authorized before the law takes effect.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill leaves “activities related to hydraulic fracturing” undefined, which could make the ban’s scope uncertain.
  • The exception means the ban would not cover every activity: some activities with a qualifying licence or permit granted before the start date would remain exempt.
  • The bill does not explain how the ban would be enforced or what penalty would apply; the supplied amendment does not include the rest of the Act’s rules on those matters.