Bill shields whistleblowers on workplace safety

Summary#

Bill 111, the Speaking Out About Workplace Violence and Workplace Harassment Act, 2019, would amend Ontario’s Occupational Health and Safety Act. Its stated goal is to protect workers from reprisals for speaking out about workplace violence, workplace harassment, and other possible breaches of the Act or its regulations.

  • No person, including an employer, could take a reprisal against a worker for acting in good faith in the ways listed in the bill.
  • The protected actions include following or seeking enforcement of the Act; seeking advice about a possible breach; supporting or serving on a health and safety committee; refusing work the worker reasonably believes violates the Act; and giving information to listed workplace, union, or enforcement contacts.
  • Protection would also cover reporting workplace violence or harassment or another possible breach, taking part in a health and safety investigation, giving evidence in relevant proceedings or an inquest, and providing information to or making a disclosure or complaint to the public.
  • A reprisal would mean any measure that adversely affects a worker’s employment. Examples include ending or threatening to end employment; demoting, disciplining or suspending a worker; penalties such as layoffs, transfers, wage cuts or changes in hours; and intimidation or coercion related to employment.
  • If enacted, the bill would take effect on Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Workers: The bill would expressly protect the listed good-faith actions from workplace reprisals. It does not require workers to report violence or harassment, take part in an investigation, or disclose information publicly.
  • Employers and other people: They would be barred from taking a reprisal for a worker’s protected actions. The bill does not set out a new report, investigation, or complaint process.
  • Workers and employers: The bill does not itself define workplace violence, workplace harassment, or “good faith.” The bill text supplied does not include the full existing Act, so the current protections and procedures cannot be verified here.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not state an appropriation, fee, fine, or staffing requirement.
  • It would create or clarify a legal prohibition, but no estimate is given for any costs of compliance or enforcement.

What is unclear#

  • The full current Occupational Health and Safety Act was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify exactly how the proposed wording differs from current law or how it interacts with existing procedures.
  • The bill does not define “good faith” or specify how decision-makers should determine whether a measure adversely affects employment.
  • It does not set out how workers would make a reprisal complaint, how such a complaint would be decided, or what remedies would be available.
  • It does not explain how the new wording would interact with any existing process for workplace violence or harassment reports.
  • The bill says it would start on Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not establish whether it became law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address the risk that workers may face negative job consequences for raising safety concerns or helping enforce the Act.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that explicitly naming reports, investigations, evidence, and public disclosures makes clear that protection extends to speaking out—not only to formal safety duties.
  • Defining reprisal broadly, while giving concrete examples, could help workers and employers recognize that penalties can include changes to pay, hours, location, or job status.

Case against#

  • The bill does not explain how workers would prove that an adverse employment measure was a reprisal or what process would resolve disputes.
  • “Good faith” and “adversely affects the worker’s employment” are not defined in the bill, leaving important questions for later interpretation.
  • The protection for public disclosures is broad, including information about any possible breach of the Act or its regulations; the bill does not explain how that protection would interact with other reporting processes.
  • The bill does not provide cost estimates or explain what resources would be needed to apply the expanded wording.